Trump’s DOJ makes sweeping demand for Colorado election knowledge : NPR

[ad_1] <img src="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/5568x3712+0+0/resize/1100/quality/50/format/jpeg/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2F2f%2F76%2Faef4af7b448ebac1150e40811d90%2Fgettyimages-2182499029.jpg" data-template="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/5568x3712+0+0/resize/{width}/quality/{quality}/format/{format}/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2F2f%2F76%2Faef4af7b448ebac1150e40811d90%2Fgettyimages-2182499029.jpg" class="img" alt="Voters walk into the Oak Creek Town Hall to drop off their ballots on Nov. 5, 2024, in Oak Creek, Colo." fetchpriority="high"/> Voters stroll into the Oak Creek City Corridor to drop off their ballots on Nov. 5, 2024, in Oak Creek, Colo. Jason Connolly/AFP by way of Getty Photos disguise caption

toggle caption

Jason Connolly/AFP by way of Getty Photos The U.S. Division of Justice is demanding an unprecedented quantity of election knowledge from at the very least one state, based on paperwork obtained by NPR, because the DOJ remodeled by the Trump administration opinions circumstances focusing on the president's political allies and caters to his want to exert extra energy over state voting processes.

On Could 12, the Justice Division requested Colorado's secretary of state to show over "all information" regarding 2024 federal elections, in addition to protect any information that stay from the 2020 election — a sprawling request a number of voting consultants and officers informed NPR was extremely uncommon and regarding, given President Trump's false claims about elections.

"What they'll do with all this knowledge, I do not know," mentioned Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold, a Democrat. "However I am certain they may use it to push their ridiculous disinformation and lies to the American public."

The request might be interpreted to incorporate voter registration supplies, ballots and voting gear, a lot of which is retained by counties, not the secretary of state. But when Colorado had been to provide all information from the 2024 common and first elections, they "would fill Mile Excessive Stadium," mentioned David Becker, a former Justice Division legal professional who labored within the Voting Part in the course of the administrations of Presidents Invoice Clinton and George W. Bush.

"It might be an unlimited quantity of data, and it is not possible the DOJ would even know what to do with all of that," mentioned Becker, who now runs the nonpartisan Heart for Election Innovation & Analysis (CEIR). "This seems extra like a fishing expedition than it does some sort of focused investigation."

Maggie Toulouse Oliver, who oversees voting because the secretary of state in neighboring New Mexico, informed NPR that she had by no means heard of such a large request from the Justice Division in her almost-20-year profession working in elections.

"I've by no means heard of something like that," mentioned Toulouse Oliver, a Democrat. "To my information, that is the primary of its sort of request."

The demand indicated that the Justice Division obtained a grievance about Colorado's election information retention, but it surely's not clear who filed the grievance or what the difficulty was. The division declined to remark or present the grievance when requested about it by NPR.

Request could also be tied to Colorado's prosecution of a Trump ally Griswold and different election officers in Colorado suspect the letter to be ultimately tied to the state's prosecution of former Mesa County Clerk Tina Peters, who has develop into a people hero amongst those that nonetheless deny the 2020 election outcomes.

Peters is serving a 9-year sentence for crimes associated to serving to an unauthorized individual acquire entry to voting gear, and as a part of her protection, she accused the secretary of state of ordering an unlawful deletion of information, although that accusation has by no means been discovered credible. Every week earlier than the DOJ despatched the letter to Colorado, Trump posted on-line that Peters was an "harmless Political Prisoner," and that the Justice Division ought to "take all vital motion" to assist free her. Earlier, in March, the division submitted a submitting in federal court docket to argue for Peters to be freed whereas she appeals her state conviction.

Nothing within the letter explicitly mentions Peters or the case, however Matt Crane, a Republican former county clerk in Colorado, mentioned it was the very first thing he considered when he heard in regards to the request.

"That was the very first thing that got here to thoughts, particularly when among the circumstances the place she mentioned she was simply backing up election information and … saying that these information ought to have been retained," mentioned Crane, who's now government director of the Colorado County Clerks Affiliation. "I believe it is partly linked to Tina." He added that he disagreed with Peters' actions and arguments and isn't conscious of wrongdoing by Griswold's workplace on report preservation.

This knowledge demand is signed by Harmeet Dhillon, who leads the DOJ Civil Rights Division, which has undergone a radical transformation because it shifts its mission to implementing Trump's government orders. The division's Voting Part has dropped voting rights lawsuits begun in the course of the Biden administration and is now prioritizing looking for voter fraud.

Its new mandate consists of implementing Trump's March 25 government order on voting, which requires the Division of Homeland Safety and the Division of Authorities Effectivity — which initiated a controversial undertaking amassing Individuals' knowledge throughout federal businesses — to evaluate state voter rolls.

Dhillon, who was confirmed in her new function April 3, beforehand served as a authorized adviser to Trump's 2020 presidential marketing campaign and Kari Lake's 2022 gubernatorial election bid in Arizona, each of which concerned unfounded conspiracy theorizing about voting.

Griswold, Colorado's secretary of state, informed NPR that whereas she's certain the info in query would solely present Colorado elections are safe, she's frightened the bizarre information request might be a part of an effort to sow doubt about American elections.

"We're seeing them use the equipment of the federal authorities to undermine our elections and our democracy," Griswold mentioned. "And I'd assume that that is extra of the identical."

A request to "ship us all the things" In latest weeks, the DOJ's Voting Part has accused states, together with North Carolina, Arizona and Oregon, of inadequately verifying voters' identities or not doing sufficient to take care of correct voter rolls.

The DOJ's information request to Colorado, nevertheless, thus far stands out in its breadth.

The letter says "we not too long ago obtained a grievance alleging noncompliance by your workplace" with election administration duties outlined within the Nationwide Voter Registration Act of 1993, and requests "all information" to guage the grievance.

"I've by no means seen a request that claims, 'You've got a duty to maintain all the things. We're investigating whether or not you saved all the things. So ship us all the things,'" mentioned Justin Levitt, a Loyola Regulation Faculty professor and former deputy assistant legal professional common within the Justice Division's Civil Rights Division in the course of the Obama administration. He additionally served as a White Home senior coverage adviser on democracy and voting rights in the course of the Biden administration.

Becker, the previous DOJ legal professional who's now with CEIR, mentioned he initially did not consider the Justice Division might really be requesting all election information from a state, however in a follow-up correspondence between Colorado and the Justice Division, appearing Voting Part chief Maureen Riordan reiterated the request in clearer phrases.

"We're requesting all information which are accessible for the federal elections that fall throughout the specified 22 months which are in your possession," she wrote, based on an e-mail change considered by NPR.

Below federal regulation, election officers should protect information for 22 months after a federal election.

Riordan acknowledged that the 22-month window had handed for the 2020 election, however wrote, "Should you nonetheless have these information from the 2020 federal elections in your possession we're requesting preservation of these information."

Colorado responded on Could 27 by offering the Justice Division with a present model of its publicly accessible voter file, a historic one capturing what the file seemed like roughly two years in the past, in addition to a dataset displaying voter historical past.

It's not clear whether or not the Justice Division will likely be glad with that response.

Each Becker and Levitt observed another oddities within the preliminary DOJ request as properly, together with quite a few typos. The letter refers to Colorado as a "commonwealth" regardless that it's a state, and it erroneously requested the state protect information from the 2000 common election as a substitute of 2020.

"Usually T's are crossed and I's dotted on the Division of Justice lengthy earlier than a letter like this goes out," Levitt mentioned. "So I've questions in regards to the substance, however I even have questions in regards to the care with which they're continuing with investigations and safeguarding supplies that they obtain — as a result of the indications listed here are that issues are coming off the rails a bit bit."

Levitt additionally questioned whether or not the Justice Division is complying with public discover procedures that federal privateness regulation requires each time the federal authorities obtains a brand new dataset that features names or different figuring out info.

Sure sections of the Justice Division have seen an exodus of legal professionals below the Trump administration. NPR has reported that as of the top of Could, about 70% of the DOJ's Civil Rights Division attorneys had left their jobs.

Riordan, however, not too long ago rejoined the DOJ, the place she beforehand spent a big chunk of profession, based on her LinkedIn profile. Riordan's final place was on the conservative Public Curiosity Authorized Basis, which has filed many lawsuits towards states it argues haven't maintained their voter lists aggressively sufficient to protect towards potential fraud.

A number of Dhillon requests <img src="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/7639x5095+0+0/resize/1100/quality/50/format/jpeg/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fcc%2Fd3%2F05b400a848b1a9477212080814a4%2Fgettyimages-2202127606.jpg" data-template="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/7639x5095+0+0/resize/{width}/quality/{quality}/format/{format}/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fcc%2Fd3%2F05b400a848b1a9477212080814a4%2Fgettyimages-2202127606.jpg" class="img" alt="Harmeet Dhillon, President Trump's then-nominee for assistant attorney general for civil rights, prepares for her confirmation hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Feb. 26." loading="lazy"/> Harmeet Dhillon, President Trump's then-nominee for assistant legal professional common for civil rights, prepares for her affirmation listening to earlier than the Senate Judiciary Committee on Feb. 26. Chip Somodevilla/Getty Photos disguise caption

toggle caption

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Photos The Justice Division letter to Colorado is not the one broad information request state officers have obtained in latest months.

On March 25 — the identical day Trump signed his voting government order — the Dhillon Regulation Group, the regulation agency Harmeet Dhillon based and labored at till her April 3 Senate affirmation, despatched 48 states and Washington, D.C., expansive voter record information requests. The letter, which was signed by a Dhillon Regulation Group associate, was despatched on behalf of the Republican Nationwide Committee, a shopper of the agency.

The requests ask for detailed info, together with the names of voters who had been eliminated for numerous causes and communications with outdoors businesses.

The RNC informed NPR in a press release that the group plans to make use of the info to evaluate "how states take away ineligible voters … and can use this info to carry states accountable and promote better transparency in our elections."

Voting consultants say it's an uncommon scenario to have an assistant legal professional common whose former agency is sending information requests that overlap with DOJ requests to states.

"Impulsively now there's these actually grey strains between her personal agency and the federal government right here," mentioned Crane, of the Colorado County Clerks Affiliation. "That appears a bit odd to me."

A Justice Division spokesperson who declined to be named informed NPR in an e-mail that Dhillon was in compliance with all moral pointers, together with recusing herself and being "ethically screened" from issues involving her former agency. Dhillon Regulation Group didn't reply to a request for remark.

Levitt mentioned whereas it was not "inherently improper" for Dhillon's former agency to be partaking in these requests, "It would not shock me in any respect if election officers had been questioning whether or not this personal request had been in actual fact getting used improperly to feed a authorities investigation. Partially as a result of there have been no assurances in any respect that this administration retains the personal sector personal and the general public sector public."

New Mexico obtained a request from the RNC by means of Dhillon Regulation Group, and Toulouse Oliver — the state's Democratic secretary of state — mentioned she worries how the info the state sends again will likely be used.

"I might envision a scenario for a non-nefarious goal [for gathering this data]," she mentioned. "It is simply given the rhetoric and given the [executive orders] which have already been ordered and issues like that, it is exhausting to consider that that is the intention."

She mentioned she is now additionally getting ready her employees in case New Mexico will get a DOJ request like Colorado.

"I believe we're all deeply involved about — are we gonna be going again to 2020, you understand, and relitigating 2020 yet again?" Toulouse Oliver mentioned. "There's simply quite a lot of uncertainty and we're all frightened that we will get focused, and in what method that's going to present itself."

Have info you wish to share about voting or elections? Attain out to those authors by means of encrypted communication on Sign. Miles Parks is at milesparks.10 and Jude Joffe-Block is at JudeJB.10. Please use a nonwork gadget.