How a 2004 legislation created an enormous pancreas harvesting increase

[ad_1] Beneath is a graph displaying a pattern that exploded throughout the 2020s:

<img alt="a bar chart showing a trend" data-chromatic="ignore" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" class="mvmjsc0" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent;background-size:cover;background-position:50% 50%;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml;charset=utf-8,%3Csvg xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg' %3E%3Cfilter id='b' color-interpolation-filters='sRGB'%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3CfeColorMatrix values='1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 100 -1' result='s'/%3E%3CfeFlood x='0' y='0' width='100%25' height='100%25'/%3E%3CfeComposite operator='out' in='s'/%3E%3CfeComposite in2='SourceGraphic'/%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3C/filter%3E%3Cimage width='100%25' height='100%25' x='0' y='0' preserveAspectRatio='none' style='filter: url(%23b);' href=''/%3E%3C/svg%3E")" sizes="(max-width: 639px) 100vw, (max-width: 1023px) 50vw, 700px" srcset="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=256 256w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=376 376w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=384 384w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=415 415w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=480 480w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=540 540w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=640 640w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=750 750w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=828 828w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1080 1080w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1200 1200w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1440 1440w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1920 1920w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=2048 2048w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=2400 2400w" src="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/aALAd-.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=2400"/> What is that this depicting? Compute use for AI? Crispr gene edits per 12 months?

No, that is one other, a lot less-known instance of large development these previous a number of years. It is a chart of the variety of pancreases (or, to make use of the right plural, “pancreata”) collected every year from useless our bodies within the US for analysis functions:

<img alt="" data-chromatic="ignore" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" class="mvmjsc0" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent;background-size:cover;background-position:50% 50%;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml;charset=utf-8,%3Csvg xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg' %3E%3Cfilter id='b' color-interpolation-filters='sRGB'%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3CfeColorMatrix values='1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 100 -1' result='s'/%3E%3CfeFlood x='0' y='0' width='100%25' height='100%25'/%3E%3CfeComposite operator='out' in='s'/%3E%3CfeComposite in2='SourceGraphic'/%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3C/filter%3E%3Cimage width='100%25' height='100%25' x='0' y='0' preserveAspectRatio='none' style='filter: url(%23b);' href=''/%3E%3C/svg%3E")" sizes="(max-width: 639px) 100vw, (max-width: 1023px) 50vw, 700px" srcset="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=256 256w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=376 376w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=384 384w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=415 415w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=480 480w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=540 540w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=640 640w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=750 750w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=828 828w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1080 1080w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1200 1200w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1440 1440w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=1920 1920w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=2048 2048w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=2400 2400w" src="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/CKmbW-pancreases-collected-for-research-have-grown-fourfold-since-2021.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0%2C100%2C100&w=2400"/> How this occurred isn't any thriller. The surge is, by all accounts, resulting from a regulation that took impact in 2021 centered on teams referred to as organ procurement organizations (OPOs).

You in all probability haven’t heard of OPOs, however for those who or anybody you already know has ever obtained an organ transplant, they’re those who procured it. OPOs are nonprofit, nongovernmental our bodies to which the US outsources the job of gathering organs from deceased organ donors. Every OPO has a monopoly on restoration of all organs in a selected geographic space; there are 55 groups , a few of which solely cowl a part of a state and a few of which cowl a number of states.

For a while now, critics have argued that OPOs are massively underusing deceased donor organs. One report from 2019 estimated that yearly 28,000 usable organs (largely badly wanted kidneys but additionally pancreata, hearts, livers, and so on.) are faraway from deceased donors however by no means used; one other put the number at 75,000 . This, when the national waitlist for organs is greater than 100,000 folks lengthy.

OPOs should not paid to gather these organs per se: They're entitled to 100 percent reimbursement of costs they report associated to retrieving, preserving, and delivering organs, with final fee coming from Medicare or transplant facilities (which in flip cost Medicare and different insurers). This method, critics have lengthy charged, doesn't present sufficient incentive to obtain harder-to-retrieve organs from sufferers who could also be older or have sure medical circumstances.

To get OPOs to gather extra organs, the Trump administration in 2019 issued an executive order calling for brand new guidelines governing how the organizations are licensed by the federal authorities, guidelines that had been finalized two years later. This was excessive stakes: If an OPO loses certification, it has to close down, and one other OPO will get its territory. The principles had been meant to extra strictly grade OPOs on the share of organs they finally transplant than the sooner, laxer guidelines did.

However there was a catch. Along with organs recovered from deceased donors and transplanted, pancreata recovered and used for analysis would depend towards recertification as effectively. Not every other organs for analysis — simply pancreata.

What occurred subsequent might be see within the chart above: an enormous, sudden surge within the variety of analysis pancreata being recovered by OPOs, starting in 2022, the exact 12 months the brand new analysis system took impact.

I’ve lengthy been fascinated by this pattern, which OPO critics name the “pancreas loophole” and OPO defenders describe as a superbly authorized response to overly onerous laws. The numbers signify 1000's of actual, bodily human pancreata, taken from actual, just lately deceased donors, that wouldn’t have been taken from these our bodies with out this regulation.

I’ve tried in current months to make sense of how this occurred, and what it means. I’m not the one one; the Senate Finance Committee has been investigating, and released a report in early June on the issue.

There's nonetheless loads that is still unknown in regards to the destiny of those pancreata (for those who work at an OPO or analysis heart and know extra particulars, please email me ). However what is obvious is that they signify an strategy by the federal authorities towards growing organ provide that completely nobody is proud of. If the purpose of the laws is to assist folks in want — together with the tens of millions of Individuals with diabetes, a illness of the pancreas — evaluating OPOs based mostly on the variety of pancreata they donate to researchers merely doesn’t make any sense.

However to know how we began judging them this fashion regardless, you need to go all the best way again to an obscure legislation handed in George W. Bush’s first time period.

Pancreata (and why you would possibly want one transplanted), defined

Everybody is aware of, in broad strokes, what the guts or the lungs do. However the pancreas doesn’t have the identical stage of fame. Its fundamental goal is to excrete enzymes, hormones, and different compounds to each 1) assist the physique digest meals and a couple of) regulate blood sugar ranges.

The latter perform is carried out by the islets of Langerhans, cells within the pancreas (named after their discoverer, Nineteenth-century German researcher Paul Langerhans) that secrete two totally different hormones: insulin (to decrease blood sugar) and glucagon (to boost it).

In Kind 1 diabetes, the power of the pancreas to provide insulin is impaired and thus blood sugar ranges are dangerously elevated; in some sorts of Kind 2 diabetes, the physique develops resistance to insulin’s results. Usually, folks with diabetes cope with this by way of injecting insulin straight, a course of that has turn into far more refined in current a long time as finger pricks and needles have given technique to insulin pumps that may straight measure and regulate blood sugar ranges.

However even with superior care, diabetes carries lifelong medical consequences , so researchers have lengthy sought a extra everlasting repair: What for those who might exchange or complement the defective islet cells in sufferers with diabetes with wholesome islet cells? May you, then, remedy diabetes on the supply and keep away from the necessity for insulin injections and the danger of long-term well being results altogether?

In probably the most excessive model of this strategy, an entire new pancreas is transplanted right into a affected person with diabetes, like swapping out a defective half. It is a confirmed therapy ( 915 occurred in 2023) and when performed it really works effectively, primarily curing the recipient’s diabetes.

However there are main downsides: you need to undertake main belly surgical procedure with a small however actual probability of failure, and if that succeeds, you need to stay on immunosuppressant medicine for the remainder of your life to stop organ rejection.

For that cause, physicians typically rule that the prices of a pancreas transplant outweigh the advantages for most individuals with diabetes. Dwelling with an insulin pump is healthier than risking surgical procedure and having a completely compromised immune system. Only a few of the 38 million Americans dwelling with diabetes, then, are going to be candidates for a pancreas transplant.

This math adjustments, nonetheless, if the affected person in query additionally wants a kidney transplant. Diabetes accounts for nearly half of all new cases of kidney failure , so a better share of individuals with diabetes than folks with out discover themselves on this state of affairs. In these circumstances, because the affected person is already going to have surgical procedure and be on immunosuppressants, throwing in a brand new pancreas to the surgical procedure and curing their diabetes in the identical operation that cures their kidney failure begins to seem like a gorgeous choice. That’s why nearly nobody will get a pancreas transplant within the US with out getting a kidney transplant too.

<img alt="Illustration of the human pancrease" data-chromatic="ignore" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" class="mvmjsc0" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent;background-size:cover;background-position:50% 50%;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml;charset=utf-8,%3Csvg xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg' %3E%3Cfilter id='b' color-interpolation-filters='sRGB'%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3CfeColorMatrix values='1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 100 -1' result='s'/%3E%3CfeFlood x='0' y='0' width='100%25' height='100%25'/%3E%3CfeComposite operator='out' in='s'/%3E%3CfeComposite in2='SourceGraphic'/%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3C/filter%3E%3Cimage width='100%25' height='100%25' x='0' y='0' preserveAspectRatio='none' style='filter: url(%23b);' href=''/%3E%3C/svg%3E")" sizes="(max-width: 639px) 100vw, (max-width: 1023px) 50vw, 700px" srcset="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=256 256w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=376 376w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=384 384w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=415 415w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=480 480w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=540 540w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=640 640w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=750 750w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=828 828w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=1080 1080w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=1200 1200w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=1440 1440w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=1920 1920w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=2048 2048w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=2400 2400w" src="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/gettyimages-857133928.jpg?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0%2C0.63385533184191%2C100%2C98.732289336316&w=2400"/> Behold, the great thing about the human pancreas. De Agostini through Getty Pictures

For many years, researchers trying to find efficient diabetes remedies have experimented with an strategy referred to as islet cell transplantation .

Relatively than transplant the entire pancreas, the process merely transplants insulin- and glucagon-producing islet cells into the recipient’s liver. It’s far much less invasive, and might be performed with native anesthesia and with out an in a single day hospital keep (although, skeptics argue, usually much less efficient than complete pancreas transplantation too). If the islet cells come from a deceased donor, it does imply a lifetime of immunosuppression, however in “autograft” procedures, which use a subset of still-healthy islets from one’s personal impaired pancreas, immunosuppression isn’t essential.

Islet cell transplantation, although, stays little-used and largely experimental within the US. A part of the rationale why is regulatory : Whereas pancreases are legally “organs,” and subsequently excluded from regulation by the Meals and Drug Administration, the FDA has asserted its authority to additionally regulate islet cells as human tissues and to require premarket approval earlier than they are often transplanted right into a affected person, identical to a drug would.

To realize such approval, it could be essential to conduct scientific research to display that the islet cells are “protected and efficient”; as soon as accepted they might must be produced in compliance with “good manufacturing practices.” To obtain islet cells not accepted by FDA, a affected person would wish to hitch a scientific research (if one is being carried out) or go to a rustic (together with Canada, Australia, and several other EU and Asian international locations) with totally different laws.

FDA’s necessities have unsurprisingly slowed the islet cell transplant subject down. The latest data comes from 2021 , when solely 10 such procedures had been carried out within the US. In 2012, 111 had been carried out, however the quantity has steadily fallen ever since. It’s orders of magnitude rarer than a whole-pancreas transplant.

However islet cell transplants have some champions, together with politicians. In 2004, Congress handed, and George W. Bush signed, the Pancreatic Islet Cell Transplantation Act . It was sponsored by Rep. George Nethercutt Jr. (R-WA), who mentioned he was pushed by his daughter’s diabetes to attempt to expand access to islet cell transplants so sufferers might “reside with out being depending on insulin injections.”

Nethercutt’s invoice sought to hurry up analysis progress by, amongst different measures, making certain satisfactory provide of pancreata for scientists. The legislation features a provision stating, “Pancreata procured by an organ procurement group and used for islet cell transplantation or analysis shall be counted for functions of certification or recertification.”

That meant that when regulators in 2019 had been reconfiguring certification guidelines for OPOs to encourage them to impact extra transplants, they had to incorporate a carve-out for pancreata used for islet cell analysis. The carve-out existed from the very first draft proposal that Trump’s Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Providers (CMS) launched, and stayed into the final rule in 2021.

The mysterious pancreas increase

That rule’s adjustments utilized for evaluations of organ procurement organizations beginning in August 2022. Within the years 2018 by way of 2021, OPOs collected round 500–600 pancreata for analysis every year. In 2022, that determine was 1,432, a three-fold enhance. In 2024, the quantity hit 2,053. The impact of the brand new regulation was clear.

It’s essential to notice that there aren't any indications that the pancreata being collected by OPOs for analysis are reducing into the availability of pancreata for donation. The share of useless folks whose pancreata are appropriate for transplant is extremely low, due to the exacting requirements for donor age and well being.

“Solely a sure variety of donors are going to be younger sufficient (in all probability lower than 50, perhaps lower than 45) and lean sufficient (perhaps lower than 30 BMI, in all probability lower than 27 or 28),” Jonathan Fridell, a transplant surgeon and director of the pancreas transplant program at IU Well being in Indianapolis, informed me. “We’re nonetheless going to take a look at the folks which might be older, nonetheless have a look at the folks which might be heavier, however the probability that they’re going to have a transplantable pancreas is decrease.” There are thus loads of non-transplantable pancreata left over that might be used for analysis as soon as the prime ones are taken away for surgical procedure.

The issue with the surge in analysis pancreata, then, isn’t that it’s taking pancreata away from recipients who want them. It’s subtler than that. By racking up massive numbers of pancreata for analysis, OPOs are bettering the grades they obtain from federal regulators, and avoiding the danger of shedding certification and having to show over territory to a different OPO. This grading and decertification course of was meant to incentivize OPOs to gather extra organs for transplant, particularly kidneys, that are both easier to transplant than pancreata and extra desperately wanted. However the analysis pancreata present a approach round that incentive.

Calculate the grades that OPOs would get with out these pancreata versus those they are getting now, and also you’ll discover the outcomes are radically totally different.

CMS classifies OPOs into three tiers : 1, 2, and three, with tier 3 OPOs dealing with decertification. Utilizing information obtained from the organ procurement transplant community, we're in a position to calculate which tier every OPO can be in with and with out their analysis pancreata based mostly on their efficiency in 2023. The 12 months that's really binding for OPOs and determines whether or not they are going to be decertification is 2024, for which information doesn't but exist, however the 2023 information provides us some indication of which OPOs are utilizing pancreata to avoid wasting themselves.

For 2 OPOs, together with analysis pancreata meant they went from tier 3, which might lead to decertification, to tier 2: Donor Community of Arizona, which covers that complete state; and OneLegacy, which incorporates most of Southern California together with Los Angeles and Orange counties. One other, Kentucky Organ Donor Associates, went from tier 2, the place it might face strain to enhance efficiency, to tier 1, suggesting it excels.

These should not small establishments. OneLegacy is by far the biggest OPO within the nation by quantity of organs collected and inhabitants coated. Its CEO, Prasad Garimella, earned $1.1 million in total compensation in 2023 , the final 12 months for which public IRS filings can be found. It stood an actual probability of being decertified if it didn't meet the brand new organ assortment requirements. And it went from reporting 83 pancreata collected for analysis in 2021 to 441 in 2022 and 492 in 2023. An over fivefold enhance, in a single 12 months — and no marvel, given its existence was at stake.

(In response to a request for remark, OneLegacy acknowledged, “When recovering organs for transplant, OneLegacy will allocate pancreata to respected islet cell analysis companies solely if they aren't viable for transplant into sufferers. Over 99.6% of pancreata recovered by OneLegacy for analysis between 2018-2022 had been allotted to 2 Nationwide Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Illnesses (NIH-NIDDK) laboratories.”)

Once more, the 2023 information isn't binding. The 2024 information shall be. However except one thing adjustments with the best way the federal government evaluates these pancreata, some main OPOs will keep away from dire penalties for the only real cause that they began gathering a whole bunch of pancreata for analysis.

The place did all of the pancreata go?

The rise is so clearly a results of the brand new guidelines that OPOs don’t even trouble to disclaim it. Responding to the Senate report earlier this month, the Association of Organ Procurement Organizations , which lobbies for the teams and towards the CMS’s stricter guidelines, mentioned merely, “Right this moment, pancreata recovered for analysis stay a part of the efficiency analysis metrics, and OPOs have operated in accordance with the rule.” In different phrases: yeah, we discovered a loophole. And what are you going to do about it?

It’s an angle that has pervaded the trade because the loophole got here to mild. In a listserv thread discussing the brand new guidelines, leaked to the Senate Finance Committee , an OPO worker wrote, “You probably have a donor with solely a pancreas for analysis, that's an organ donor for the Donor Fee. In any other case, a donor is any donor with at the very least 1 organ transplanted. Savvy (or cynical?) OPOs ought to begin a pancreas for analysis program instantly.”

However there’s a query that is still unanswered: The place did all these 1000's of pancreata go?

It's clear that the overwhelming majority of analysis pancreata did not go into islet transplants. We're speaking about 1000's of organs, not the few dozen that plausibly might have been transplanted as a part of islet procedures previously couple of years.

Certainly, OPOs have admitted as a lot. The Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Providers asks OPOs for information on organs recovered yearly, and in August 2024 clarified that it could solely depend pancreata as “‘used’ for analysis if they're accepted to be used in bona fide islet cell analysis carried out by a professional researcher, comparable to analysis accepted by the Nationwide Institutes of Well being.” It then requested OPOs to resubmit their information, clarifying which organs had been for islet cell analysis particularly.

As soon as they did, the variety of reported pancreata fell dramatically:

<img alt="" data-chromatic="ignore" loading="lazy" decoding="async" data-nimg="fill" class="mvmjsc0" style="position:absolute;height:100%;width:100%;left:0;top:0;right:0;bottom:0;color:transparent;background-size:cover;background-position:50% 50%;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml;charset=utf-8,%3Csvg xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg' %3E%3Cfilter id='b' color-interpolation-filters='sRGB'%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3CfeColorMatrix values='1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 100 -1' result='s'/%3E%3CfeFlood x='0' y='0' width='100%25' height='100%25'/%3E%3CfeComposite operator='out' in='s'/%3E%3CfeComposite in2='SourceGraphic'/%3E%3CfeGaussianBlur stdDeviation='20'/%3E%3C/filter%3E%3Cimage width='100%25' height='100%25' x='0' y='0' preserveAspectRatio='none' style='filter: url(%23b);' href=''/%3E%3C/svg%3E")" sizes="(max-width: 639px) 100vw, (max-width: 1023px) 50vw, 700px" srcset="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=256 256w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=376 376w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=384 384w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=415 415w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=480 480w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=540 540w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=640 640w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=750 750w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=828 828w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=1080 1080w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=1200 1200w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=1440 1440w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=1920 1920w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=2048 2048w, https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=2400 2400w" src="https://platform.vox.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/06/SkF9M-only-about-half-the-research-pancreata-reported-by-organ-procurement-organizations-went-to-islet-cell-transplantation-research.png?quality=90&strip=all&crop=0.24193548387097%2C0%2C99.516129032258%2C100&w=2400"/> In 2023, the full went from 3,338 pancreata earlier than the steering, to 1,812 after, a drop of 46 p.c. Some OPOs, like Legacy of Hope in Alabama, now reported zero pancreata for analysis; earlier than the steering narrowed qualifying functions, Legacy of Hope had claimed 226 pancreata.

However even after the change in steering, we’re left with smaller numbers which might be nonetheless a lot too large to be defined by bona fide islet cell transplants. There merely weren't 1,812 islet cell transplants within the US in 2023, however there have been 1,812 pancreata credited as donated for islet cell analysis. And that quantity remains to be over triple the quantity claimed in 2021, that means the rise sparked by the brand new OPO guidelines largely stays even after the federal government’s clarification. Analysis by David Goldberg, Erin Tewksbury, and Matthew Wadsworth has proven that the variety of pancreata reported as recovered by OPOs additionally swamps the quantity that the Integrated Islet Distribution Program (IIDP) , a consortium that collects and extracts islet cells from pancreata, experiences receiving from these OPOs.

One of many factors of the Senate investigation was to find out the place precisely these pancreata went. The Senate Finance Committee, with the good thing about subpoena energy, went about asking main OPOs for what precise goal the analysis pancreata had been used. The principle reply they obtained was “we don’t know.”

“Lots of the OPOs acknowledged that it's the accountability of the analysis amenities or establishments receiving the pancreata to tell the OPOs on the aim, strategies, and efficacy of the analysis being carried out on the pancreata and different organs that OPOs provide,” the report states. In different phrases, OPOs themselves don’t maintain monitor. “Many of those OPOs,” the report continues, “have despatched pancreata to biobanks and different establishments or amenities that maintain pancreata for an unknown interval for use for functions that could be undefined or nonexistent.”

Put one other approach: These pancreata might, for all of the OPOs or the Senate is aware of, be sitting on a freezer someplace, not transplanted into anybody. Or perhaps not even sitting there in any respect. Greg Segal, an activist advocating for reform to the pancreas loophole, testified earlier than a Home committee that workers at one OPO, joked “that they’re conducting analysis on the efficacy of rubbish disposal A versus rubbish disposal B” when disposing of pancreata.

All through all this, OPOs have had one constant message: They’ve complied with the legislation, as they see it.

“Pancreata recovered for analysis stay a part of the efficiency analysis metrics, and OPOs have operated in accordance with the rule,” the Affiliation of Organ Procurement Organizations, the teams’ lobbying store in Washington, mentioned in its assertion after the Senate investigation was launched. “When CMS issued clarifying steering in 2024 limiting this metric to pancreata used for islet cell analysis, OPOs responded instantly and labored with the company to validate information and guarantee compliance.”

Jedd Lewis, CEO of the Organ Preservation Alliance and a decades-long veteran of the transplant subject, notes that CMS’s rule uncared for to outline what it means to make use of a pancreas for analysis, regardless of many OPOs and trade consultants particularly flagging the issue for CMS earlier than that rule took impact. And CMS’s new steering final 12 months did little to unravel the issue, he argues.

“Final years’ memos merely recognized the scope of pancreas donations that OPOs can be judged on as these for ‘islet cell analysis.’ However CMS didn’t outline what that truly means …and on its face it’s an enormous scope of analysis,” Lewis wrote in an e-mail. “There are such a lot of … ways in which researchers are taking a look at how these cells perform: finding out the pancreas complete, slicing it into skinny sections, isolating the person islet cells, even breaking the cells into the element components.” That’s all invaluable analysis, he argues, and clearly pertains to islet cells, even when the pancreata are by no means really utilized in islet cell transplants.

Wadsworth, a coauthor on the research discovering a surge in analysis pancreata and CEO of the LifeConnection OPO in northwest Ohio, concedes that counting pancreata that didn't produce islet cells for transplant might technically be authorized. However he nonetheless thinks it’s incorrect.

“I labored with this surgeon early on in my profession who mentioned ‘simply because you are able to do one thing doesn’t imply it's best to,’ Wadsworth famous. “Based mostly on what’s written, perhaps they didn’t do something incorrect, however you don’t should look far again in historical past to search out examples the place one thing wasn’t unlawful, but it surely positively wasn’t proper both.”

LifeConnection, Wadsworth says, was in a position to adjust to the spirit of the CMS laws by discovering counties in its jurisdiction the place low numbers of organs had been being procured, and dealing on fixing the issue hospital-by-hospital. It’s tougher than simply harvesting pancreata, but it surely means organs get transplanted to individuals who want them.

One irony of the controversy is that the majority OPOs, and their representatives, don’t consider that analysis pancreata ought to depend for his or her evaluations. “AOPO has issues about together with pancreata utilized for analysis within the information used to calculate the numerator of both proposed measure,” the Affiliation of Organ Procurement Organizations wrote in an early 2020 comment because the laws had been being developed. “The utilization of pancreata for analysis is pushed by demand of native researchers. Inclusion of pancreata for analysis within the information utilized for the numerator might skew comparisons of OPOs in that class and doubtlessly result in inaccurate conclusions.”

However each the OPOs and their regulator, CMS, had been sure by the 2004 legislation requiring that analysis pancreata, at the very least that for islet cell analysis, should depend for these evaluations.

We're operating out of time to repair this downside. If nothing adjustments, OPOs shall be evaluated on the idea of information they’ve submitted now, together with a whole bunch of pancreata that had been by no means used for islet cell transplants. Whether or not you assume that displays OPOs complying in good religion, or subverting the system, it’s not a coverage anybody ought to assume makes a lot sense.

CMS has some means to behave right here — however maybe one of the best repair would come from Congress within the type of a authorized provision clarifying the 2004 act. Merely repealing the availability proscribing how OPOs might be evaluated can be easiest — however even higher can be pairing it with a authorized change that would assist islet transplantation analysis way over the 2004 has up to now.

Recall that islet transplants presently don’t depend as organ transplants within the US. They depend as remedies with organic tissue ““If islet cells are solely organs, as a result of they're a subpart of the pancreas, which is an organ below transplant legislation, then the FDA shouldn't have jurisdiction,” Gail Javitt, a veteran lawyer engaged on FDA regulatory points on the agency Hyman, Phelps & McNamara, informed me. “Nevertheless, FDA has taken a special place, that islet cells are a mobile remedy and should bear premarket approval identical to a drug would.” If you wish to use it for therapy of a affected person, you need to undergo them. That has had the sensible influence of slowing down the supply of islet cells for transplantation on this nation.”

Legally clarifying that islet cells are organs, not mobile therapies, and that they're excluded from FDA oversight then, might go an extended technique to selling the therapy. Final Congress, Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) and Rep. Matthew Rosendale (R-MT) every launched payments making this modification, with solely Republican co-sponsors.

However this needn't be a partisan problem in any respect, and for those who paired this provision with a repeal of the 2004 legislation allowing OPOs to depend pancreata for analysis as a part of its transplant metrics, you possibly can arrive at a near best system. OPOs can be evaluated on their means to transplant islet cells, as a result of they’d be organs like every other. They might not be capable of get larger scores by recovering pancreata for analysis which may simply languish on a shelf.

This does require Congress to make a small change. However it’s a small change that needs to be mainly uncontroversial. There’s nothing for many OPOs or for advocates attempting to maximise donations to dislike right here, and there’s tons for islet cell researchers to like. It’s a small repair that would go a really good distance.

You’ve learn 1 article within the final month

Right here at Vox, we're unwavering in our dedication to overlaying the problems that matter most to you — threats to democracy, immigration, reproductive rights, the atmosphere, and the rising polarization throughout this nation.

Our mission is to offer clear, accessible journalism that empowers you to remain knowledgeable and engaged in shaping our world. By changing into a Vox Member, you straight strengthen our means to ship in-depth, impartial reporting that drives significant change.