SCOTUS SMACKDOWN! Amy Coney Barrett Shreds Ketanji Brown Jackson Over Birthright Citizenship Dissent

[ad_1]

ACB benches KBJ…

In keeping with a New York Submit report, Supreme Court docket Justice Amy Coney Barrett shocked longtime court docket watchers Friday with a pointy rebuke of Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson’s “excessive” dissent within the landmark birthright citizenship ruling.

Barrett, writing for the conservative majority, dismissed Jackson’s objections as out of step with each precedent and precept, because the Court docket moved to rein within the sweeping use of common injunctions by decrease courts.

“We won't dwell on Justice Jackson’s argument, which is at odds with greater than two centuries’ price of precedent, to not point out the Structure itself,” wrote Barrett in a pointy rebuke of her colleague.

“We observe solely this: Justice Jackson decries an imperial Government whereas embracing an imperial Judiciary.”

From The New York Submit:

Barrett had authored the bulk opinion within the case, probably the most consequential on the docket this time period, which gave President Trump a serious win by limiting the ability of district judges to dam his actions.

Liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor penned the principle dissent for the left flank of the excessive court docket, which Jackson joined.

However Jackson additionally wrote a concurring dissent that featured a heavy fixation on the potential sensible ramifications of the 6-3 choice somewhat than grounding her argument in authorized principle.

“It isn't troublesome to foretell how this all ends. Ultimately, government energy will develop into utterly uncontainable, and our beloved constitutional Republic can be no extra,” Jackson dramatically fretted at one level.

“Fairly in contrast to a rule-of-kings governing system, in a rule of legislation regime, practically ‘[e]very act of presidency could also be challenged by an enchantment to legislation,’” Jackson wrote elsewhere. “On the very least, I lament that almost all is so caught up in trivia of the Authorities’s self-serving, finger-pointing arguments that it misses the plot.”

Jackson even went as far as to dismiss the query of whether or not common injunctions have been offered for by the Judiciary Act of 1789 as “legalese” that “obscures a much more primary query of huge authorized and sensible significance: Might a federal court docket in the US of America order the Government to comply with the legislation?”

Barrett’s response in her opinion was virtually mocking: “As a result of analyzing the governing statute includes boring ‘legalese,’ [Jackson] seeks to reply ‘a much more primary query of huge sensible significance: Might a federal court docket in the US of America order the Government to comply with the legislation?’

“In different phrases, it's pointless to contemplate whether or not Congress has constrained the Judiciary; what issues is how the Judiciary might constrain the Government. Justice Jackson would do nicely to heed her personal admonition: ‘[E]veryone, from the President on down, is certain by legislation,’” Barrett continued.

“That goes for judges too.”

Amy Coney Barrett’s full evisceration of Ketanji Brown Jackson is under. She’s principally asking how KBJ handed the bar. pic.twitter.com/skHbUpDSbL

— Clay Travis (@ClayTravis) June 27, 2025

Extra over at The New York Submit:

Amy Coney Barrett rips Ketanji Brown Jackson over dissent in birthright citizenship case: ‘As brutal as I’ve ever seen’ pic.twitter.com/Kqu1fVQbCL

— New York Submit (@nypost) June 27, 2025

[ad_2] Source link

SCOTUS SMACKDOWN! Amy Coney Barrett Shreds Ketanji Brown Jackson Over Birthright Citizenship Dissent

High Hamas army commander tied to October 7 assault killed in airstrike – One America Information Community

Majority of Individuals again sanctions on Russia, allies that buy oil: Survey

1975 frontman Matty Healy vows to finish politics regardless of contradictory present

greater

Related Posts

High Hamas army commander tied to October 7 assault killed in airstrike – One America Information Community

Majority of Individuals again sanctions on Russia, allies that buy oil: Survey

1975 frontman Matty Healy vows to finish politics regardless of contradictory present

Florida Is Not the Paradise You Could Envision – RedState

‘We Must Defend the Feminine Class’ from Trans Athletes

Democrats who locked down America throughout COVID now cry dictator over Trump's deportations

Trump ends commerce talks with Canada over a digital providers tax

Mamdani Vows to Decrease Prices However His ‘Repair’ is Extra Lefty Insurance policies That Drive Them Up

Recommended Stories

BetSaracen early SEC soccer common season odds

US reaches cope with China to hurry up rare-earth shipments, White Home says | Worldwide commerce

Save as much as 44% on HexClad cookware throughout its Fourth of July bundle sale

Popular Stories

Diddy And Justin Combs Face Gang-Rape Allegations

A $16 Trillion Path: AR Tokens, Which Can Shut the Hole Between TradFi and DeFi

How To Cease Alopecia Areata From Spreading

Israeli navy detains 6 settlers after assault on forces in occupied West Financial institution

Hundreds Collect in Tehran to Mourn Useless from Israel Strikes

Categories

Site Map

Recent Posts

Welcome Back!

Create New Account!

Retrieve your password

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?

Are you sure want to cancel subscription?

SCOTUS SMACKDOWN! Amy Coney Barrett Shreds Ketanji Brown Jackson Over Birthright Citizenship Dissent

RELATED POSTS

Support Greater and Subscribe to view content

Subscribe

Related Posts

Recommended Stories

Popular Stories

Categories

Site Map

Recent Posts

Welcome Back!

Create New Account!

Retrieve your password

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?

Are you sure want to cancel subscription?