Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has denied that Palestinians in Gaza are ravenous. “There is no such thing as a hunger in Gaza, no coverage of hunger in Gaza,” Netanyahu said on Sunday, throughout an occasion with Daystar, an evangelical TV community, held in Jerusalem.
His remarks stand in stark distinction to mounting proof from help companies, humanitarian organizations and eyewitnesses who describe an escalating meals disaster, significantly within the north of the enclave.
A DW truth verify takes a more in-depth look.
What the studies say
The Built-in Meals Safety Part Classification (IPC), a worldwide starvation monitoring physique, has warnedthat famine thresholds have been surpassed in components of Gaza, significantly in Gaza Metropolis, calling the disaster a “worst-case state of affairs” now unfolding.
In response to the World Health Organization, 63 of the 74 malnutrition-related deaths recorded in Gaza this yr occurred in July alone — together with 38 adults and 24 kids underneath the age of 5.
In the meantime, aid workers on the ground report they themselves are going hungry and Gaza’s Well being Ministry has mentioned dozens of individuals have died from starvation-related causes over the previous three weeks.
With worldwide strain rising, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer mentioned Tuesday the UK would formally recognize a state of Palestine on the UN Normal Meeting in September except Israel takes “substantive steps to finish the appalling state of affairs in Gaza.”
Netanyahu, Israel ‘blame Hamas’ for meals shortages
Israeli officers, nevertheless, together with Overseas Ministry spokesperson Oren Marmorstein, have rejected the malnutrition and hunger figures launched by Gaza’s well being authorities and UN our bodies, calling them exaggerated and unreliable.
They argue that the numbers, some offered by Hamas, a bunch designated as a terrorist group by Israel, the EU and others, lack credibility. Nonetheless, a new independent study has mentioned they’re truly too low.
Prime Minister Netanyahu just isn’t alone in denying that Gaza is dealing with hunger. His feedback have been echoed throughout social media by quite a few on-line personalities and accounts that both downplay the severity of the disaster or declare studies of widespread starvation are fabricated.
Israel imposed an entire blockade of meals, gasoline and different provides in March and quite a few politicians — together with Netanyahu — have repeatedly mentioned no meals would enter Gaza. In August 2024, Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich mentioned “it is likely to be justified and ethical” to let Israel “trigger 2 million civilians to die of starvation” till the “hostages are returned.”
“That is the official line repeated by the prime minister, his cupboard and the far-right media,” Oren Persico of the Israeli unbiased outlet The Seventh Eye instructed DW. “They both deny that hunger is going on, blame Hamas for not surrendering and even declare it is a good factor — as a result of it supposedly helps pave the way in which for constructing Jewish settlements in Gaza.”
Pictures of emaciated kids mentioned to be deceptive
In latest days, a number of influential accounts have challenged extensively shared images of severely emaciated kids in Gaza, claiming they’re deceptive or lack context. One picture — of Muhammad Zakariya Ayyoub al-Matouq — featured in reports by several international news outlets has additionally circulated extensively on social media alongside posts condemning the humanitarian disaster.
Professional-Israel commentators, together with Israel’s Overseas Ministry, later mentioned the boy had a uncommon genetic muscular dysfunction and alleged that omitting this element was an try and defame Israel.
Whereas some posts and studies did lack that context, outlets like CNN acknowledged his situation and famous that he had been dwelling a more healthy life earlier than the battle, due to remedy and satisfactory vitamin. “He has a muscle dysfunction that requires bodily remedy and specialised vitamin, and he faces life-threatening malnutrition because the humanitarian state of affairs worsens resulting from ongoing Israeli assaults and the blockade,” mentioned a photograph caption.
The New York Occasions also confirmed the boy suffered from malnutrition along with a pre-existing sickness.
Nonetheless, numerous accounts proceed to flow into the declare that such images have been being misused to falsely recommend hunger — one thing they insist doesn’t exist.
One extensively shared publish (see screenshot under) reads: “A boy from Gaza with a uncommon muscular illness is being exploited to advertise the faux marketing campaign of hunger in Gaza.” DW Fact Check recognized dozens of almost an identical posts circulating the identical picture and textual content.
‘Pre-existing medical situation doesn’t rule out malnutrition’
Our staff confirmed the image shared by these posts to a number of pediatricians in Germany to confirm the claims in regards to the kid’s muscular dysfunction. The docs famous that the precise situation can’t be recognized from images and movies alone.
Nonetheless, they emphasised {that a} pre-existing medical situation doesn’t rule out malnutrition, and attributing all indicators of emaciation solely to genetic problems overlooks the broader influence of extended dietary deficiency.
For Oren Persico from The Seventh Eye, the accusations from the Israeli authorities are a part of a political technique. “One tactic getting used is to focus on non-representative examples and current them as proof that human struggling in Gaza is not occurring,” he defined.
“It is like conspiracy theories [that] repair on irrelevant particulars to distort the general image. In that sense, I’d name it a disinformation marketing campaign — one which cherry-picks fringe info to disclaim the overwhelming physique of proof, together with eyewitness accounts, knowledge and studies.”
Bustling meals market in Gaza?
An analogous narrative surfaced round a bit of video revealed by shops together with the The Jerusalem Post which reveals a close-up of a vegetable stall in a Gaza market. The footage shortly unfold throughout social media, the place it was utilized by accounts looking for to problem studies of famine within the territory.
“That is footage from immediately at Al-Sahaba market in Gaza Metropolis, fully filled with meals. A lot for hunger. The common Gazan eats higher than you!”, writes one account.
Support Greater and Subscribe to view content
This is premium stuff. Subscribe to read the entire article.
