Survey reveals faculty college students confused about socialism and what it might imply

[ad_1] NEW Now you can take heed to Fox Information articles!

The current New York main win by Democrat Zohran Mamdani, a self-proclaimed socialist, raises the query that has been simmering for years: Is America prepared for socialism?

Our nationwide survey of two,067 faculty and college college students throughout the U.S. suggests the reply begins with one other query: What constitutes socialism? Solely 34% of scholars outline socialism as state possession and central planning, the basic definition. Nearly half as a substitute outline it as energetic authorities and redistribution, and plenty of admit they're uncertain. This confusion shapes how folks speak about socialism and why it polls properly with younger voters.

Politicians have helped blur the strains by pointing to locations reminiscent of Nordic nations like Sweden as fashions of "democratic socialism," claiming they're profitable fashions of what it may appear like within the U.S. However Sweden shouldn't be a socialist economic system. The insurance policies endorsed by Vermont Impartial Sen. Bernie Sanders, New York Democrat Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Mamdani and others — like implementing a wealth tax, rising inheritance taxes, company taxes and earnings taxes to pay for a big welfare state — aren't the insurance policies of Sweden. It's a market-based system with excessive taxes that fund a beneficiant welfare state.

US SUPPORT FOR CAPITALISM SINKS TO NEW LOW IN GALLUP POLL

Whereas the tax burden for people is comparatively excessive in Sweden, the Swedish authorities notes that its welfare system is constructed on the precept that everybody pays, not simply the wealthy. The highest marginal earnings tax fee is increased in Sweden than within the U.S. However these increased taxes aren’t simply being paid by the wealthy in Sweden. The highest fee applies to everybody incomes barely above the nationwide common in Sweden, in comparison with the U.S. the place the best fee is paid by these incomes 800% increased than the nationwide common.

Sen. Bernie Sanders, Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez pose for a photograph in Astoria, Queens, Sept. 6, 2025. (@ZohranKMamdani by way of X)

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

Furthermore, Sweden imposes a 25% consumption tax on items and companies, versus state and native gross sales taxes within the U.S. that common 7.7%. Sweden additionally has no wealth tax, no inheritance tax and a decrease company tax fee than within the U.S.

Sweden realized the exhausting means what occurs when it moved towards the sort of insurance policies advocated for by "democratic socialists." As highlighted by Johan Norberg and others, for nearly 100 years, the nation had a small authorities and an open economic system till the nation experimented with socialism within the ’70s and ’80s. Throughout that point, they expanded the scale of presidency, elevated earnings taxes, launched a wealth tax and an inheritance tax. Iconic firms like IKEA left the nation, development stalled and the nation skilled a monetary disaster that compelled main reforms within the early Nineties. Right now, Sweden is among the most economically free nations on this planet.

FETTERMAN RIPS ‘LEFTIES’ IN DEM PARTY, SAYING PEOPLE IN EX-COMMUNIST NATION TOLD HIM ‘YOU ARE MORONS'

So, what do younger People need? Once we requested college students whether or not they're in favor of common healthcare and free increased training, 78% stated sure whether it is funded by a wealth tax on the highest 1%. Seventy-one % stated sure if funded by increased earnings taxes on the highest 10%. When requested whether or not they had been in favor of this stuff if funded by a common consumption tax, assist dropped to half. When funded by a better earnings tax on most individuals, solely 38% had been in favor. Clearly, faculty college students (and presumably different People who're in favor of this stuff) are way more in favor of a bigger welfare state if anyone else foots the invoice.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP

Historical past and economics present that the techniques constructed on ever-expanding authorities ultimately hit a wall. Because the late British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher famously stated, "The issue with socialism is that you simply ultimately run out of different folks’s cash."

Earlier than America decides it's prepared for socialism, it’s clear we have to get educated on what it really means and what it actually prices. Solely then can we actually debate whether or not socialism is "a dedication to dignity," as Mamdani says, or whether or not it's a prescription for spoil.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM JOHN BITZAN

John Bitzan is a professor of administration and the Menard Household Director at the Challey Institute for World Innovation and Development at North Dakota State College.