How her case differs from different lacking individuals : NPR

[ad_1] <img src="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/2326x1702+0+0/resize/1100/quality/50/format/png/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fad%2Fa4%2F61ebdc524524baa12c92fa03c4e1%2Fscreenshot-2026-02-12-at-2-19-49-pm.png" data-template="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/2326x1702+0+0/resize/{width}/quality/{quality}/format/{format}/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fad%2Fa4%2F61ebdc524524baa12c92fa03c4e1%2Fscreenshot-2026-02-12-at-2-19-49-pm.png" class="img" alt="Screenshot 2026-02-12 at 2.19.49 PM.png" fetchpriority="high"/>

Nancy Guthrie's case has drawn extensive consideration, partly due to the distinctive circumstances of her disappearance. She's seen right here alongside different people who find themselves listed on the FBI's Kidnappings and Lacking Individuals web page as of Thursday morning./FBI/ Screenshot by NPR The kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie is placing a highlight on the excruciating uncertainty endured by 1000's of households whose family members go lacking annually. Specialists see parallels with these circumstances, at the same time as many particulars in Guthrie's case are distinctive, from the sufferer's age to her superstar daughter, As we speak present co-host Savannah Guthrie.

The circumstances of Guthrie's disappearance are "fairly surprising," says Jesse Goliath, a forensic anthropologist at Mississippi State College.

"Normally you hear about smaller kids, juveniles that go lacking" and attracting nationwide press, Goliath says. "However having an older lady who's gone lacking and having [a daughter] that you have seen on TV daily" is extraordinary, he provides.

Greater than 500,000 individuals have been reported lacking within the U.S. final yr, in response to the Justice Division. However Tara Kennedy, media consultant for the Doe Community, a volunteer group working to determine lacking and unidentified individuals, says high-profile kidnappings are uncommon.

"I am unable to keep in mind the final time I heard a few ransom case moreover Guthrie," says Kennedy, who has labored with the Doe Community since 2014. "I at all times affiliate them with completely different durations in American historical past, just like the Lindbergh kidnapping, not somebody's mom from the As we speak present."

Each Kennedy and Goliath describe the Guthrie case as "unusual." Here is a rundown of issues it has in frequent with different missing-persons circumstances, and why it is uncommon:

Key particulars which can be "exceptional" From June 2020 to June 2025, ladies comprised greater than 75% of the victims within the some 240,000 circumstances of kidnappings or abductions that have been reported within the U.S., in response to FBI crime knowledge. However of these, solely 646 ladies have been of their 80s like Nancy Guthrie, who's 84, or lower than .2% of all victims. Evaluate that to the age group that accounted for the biggest variety of victims that yr: individuals 20-29, who made up simply shy of 30% of victims.

Different extremely uncommon revelations have emerged as her disappearance has persevered: from purported ransom notes despatched to media retailers demanding thousands and thousands of {dollars} to unsettling photographs of a masked gunman approaching Guthrie's entrance door on the night time she disappeared.

Taken collectively, it is like one thing out of a real crime novel, Goliath says: "That is one thing exceptional."

In missing-person circumstances, a fast response is essential TV exhibits have helped perpetuate a fable that households have to attend 24 hours earlier than reporting a beloved one as lacking. However some exhibits and films do get one factor proper: The primary 24 to 48 hours are important to finding somebody who has disappeared.

"Normally loads of them are going to be [found] inside 24 hours, particularly the juvenile and younger grownup circumstances," Goliath says.

In that early timeframe, eyewitness reviews is likely to be extra helpful; sniffer canines may have a more energizing scent to comply with; and surveillance video and different digital knowledge is extra prone to be intact and useful.

"The longer the individual is lacking, the harder it turns into" to seek out them, Kennedy says, citing decades-old unresolved circumstances.

Then there's the sufferer's well being. Whether or not the topic of a search operation wandered off and received misplaced, or was kidnapped or trafficked, Goliath notes that after 48 hours, their well-being may very well be compromised — by the weather, or by well being points resembling Nancy Guthrie's pacemaker and her want for every day treatment.

"Sadly, if that individual is just not discovered inside that first two days, their possibilities of survival drop exponentially," Goliath says.

Who're the individuals who go lacking within the U.S.? At any given second, about 100,000 persons are thought of lacking within the U.S., in response to Goliath and Kennedy. On the finish of 2024, for example, the Nationwide Crime Data Heart — listed greater than 93,000 lively missing-persons circumstances within the U.S., whereas a complete of 533,936 circumstances have been entered into the federal monitoring system that yr.

Of these circumstances, greater than 60% — or roughly 330,000 — concerned juveniles, in response to the NCIC database, which regulation enforcement businesses use to share legal warrants, missing-person alerts, and different data.

Amongst people who find themselves reported lacking, Goliath says there's an "overrepresentation of Black and Indigenous populations who go lacking, particularly females, throughout the US."

In Mississippi, he provides, "Our highest demographic of lacking [persons] is younger Black females."

Black Individuals are additionally overrepresented in abductions. Whereas members of the group make up lower than 15% of the U.S. inhabitants, they account for greater than 25% of the victims in reported abductions or kidnappings, in response to the FBI's knowledge.

However numerous missing-persons circumstances additionally go unreported, as a result of some communities, resembling individuals of coloration or those that do not have documented standing within the U.S., are much less prone to interact with authorities. And Goliath notes that Indigenous individuals dwelling on reservations may need restricted entry to regulation enforcement.

One other dynamic that skews public notion, Kennedy says, is "lacking white lady syndrome," when nationwide media develop into fixated on a white lady who has disappeared.

"As somebody who researches chilly circumstances by way of on the lookout for data, the disparity of data on the market, of circumstances for individuals of coloration is ridiculous," she says.

Calling for motion, simpler methods to share knowledge Goliath says each missing-person case, not simply Guthrie's, must be extensively broadcast and shared, to extend the possibility of bringing somebody dwelling.

"We name this a silent disaster," he says, "that there are individuals lacking in the US, all through the nation that actually do not have that very same social media illustration or a nationwide media illustration for his or her circumstances."

It is also tough to seek out standardized knowledge for lacking individuals, because of a patchwork of guidelines and assets. It is solely obligatory for regulation enforcement businesses throughout the nation to report lacking individuals circumstances to the federal authorities in the event that they contain minors, for example.

Along with NCIC, lacking individuals knowledge is collected by NamUs (the Nationwide Lacking and Unidentified Individuals System), which provides public entry. However as of now, solely 16 states require obligatory reporting to the NamUs clearinghouse for lacking individuals circumstances.

Goliath says he'd wish to see a nationwide push for extra states to undertake NamUs necessities. As NPR reported final yr, a big portion of U.S. police businesses weren't listed within the system.

"That'd be a assist, as a result of it is already a system that exists," Goliath says. "Regulation enforcement already is doing it. So, let's simply have all of the states be capable to use NamUs."