Darnold, Mayfield and Sagapolutele: who would be the NFL’s subsequent first-time MVP?

[ad_1] There was a development in latest NFL seasons. Round Week 8, the MVP race begins to observe a predictable script: Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson (if the Ravens are rolling) will virtually actually characteristic.

Between 2015 and 2019, the NFL had 4 first-time MVP winners – Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, Mahomes and Jackson. However within the final 5 years, solely Allen has been a first-time winner (Aaron Rodgers, Mahomes and Jackson have been the opposite victors).

Commercial

Allen is favourite to go back-to-back this season, which might make it 5 occasions within the final six years the league has topped a earlier winner. However voters expertise fatigue; everybody desires a contemporary star. And this yr’s record of first-time candidates feels unusually deep and unusually enjoyable. Possibly these guys received’t win this yr, however let’s have a look at the gamers who might break up the Mahomes-Allen-Jackson triumvirate within the subsequent few seasons.

Just a few notes: the rankings beneath are for the gamers’ possibilities of profitable the award within the subsequent few years, not particularly this season. We’ve additionally disregarded perennial contenders like Joe Burrow, Matthew Stafford and Dak Prescott in favor of some longer photographs.

Sam Darnold, Seattle Seahawks It’s now not a joke: Darnold is without doubt one of the finest quarterbacks within the NFL. In Minnesota, it was simple to scoff at his ascent. You would level to the schematic surroundings and his wonderful supporting solid. That’s not the case in Seattle.

Commercial

The Seahawks’ run recreation has but to gel. The offensive line is improved, however nonetheless lags behind the league’s finest. Jaxon Smith-Njigba has been one of many 5 finest receivers within the league this yr, however has been elevated by the decision-making and accuracy of Darnold.

Associated: Jets, Ravens … Eagles? Which group is most depressing after 5 weeks of the NFL season?

Seattle have retooled their offense round Darnold, who remains to be solely 28 (youthful than Burrow, who was drafted two years later). They hunt chunk performs, banking on Darnold’s arm to push the ball down the sector. In that position, he appears to be like extra like Stafford than the Darnold we noticed throughout his Jets years. Early in his profession, Darnold struggled when pressured, staring down the frenzy and gagging away expensive turnovers. He’s stripped a lot of that fats from his recreation. The place as soon as he noticed ghosts, now he's creating performs when his safety breaks down or the construction of the offense is off.

Bounce via no matter quarterback metric you want, and Darnold is on the prime, or close to the highest, of the record. He leads the league within the RBSDM composite, which items collectively the worth of each offensive play and measures how a lot a quarterback will be deemed accountable for that worth. Whoever tops that quantity by the tip of the yr usually winds up within the ultimate three in MVP voting.

Commercial

By 5 weeks, Darnold has proved final season in Minnesota was no fluke. That is who he's now, and that’s been an improve for Seattle over Geno Smith. If he can lead the Seahawks to a division title, the redemption narrative will carry him into the dialog with Allen and Mahomes.

MVP probability: 7/10. This yr might be his finest probability to win it.

Baker Mayfield, Tampa Bay Buccaneers Talking of redemption arcs. There was a time when the Panthers employed Baker Mayfield and Darnold. Oof. Mayfield has gone from scout group pass-rusher in Carolina to franchise quarterback in Tampa Bay.

The MVP is, to an extent, a story award, and few have a cooler story than Mayfield. Burrow, Stafford and Prescott are higher quarterbacks. However there's something about his story that ought to garner additional credit score amongst voters. A number of franchises gave up on him earlier than he arrived in Tampa. He’s had three completely different offensive coordinators within the final three seasons, however has continued to pilot the Bucs offense on the highest stage.

Commercial

Mayfield hasn’t been as clear this yr as he was in 2024. Right down to down, he’s been just a little scattershot. However he’s working in a tough surroundings: Tampa’s run recreation has stalled, and the offensive line has been weakened by accidents. But regardless of these issues, Mayfield is enjoying the perfect all-around ball of his profession. He’s already led the Bucs to 4 game-winning drives this season and he leads the league in Massive Time Throw Charge, in response to Professional Soccer Focus. He's doing extra with much less, together with waltzing into Seattle with a beat-up line and dropping 38 factors on the most effective defenses in soccer (although one which had loads of damage points to take care of of its personal).

In a time earlier than superior analytics, Mayfield can be main this yr’s race. He has put his group on his again greater than some other quarterback in crunch time. Voters nonetheless worth that stuff, however not fairly to the identical diploma they did within the Nineties and early 2000s.

MVP probability: 4/10. His gambler model will lead him to throw a couple of video games away.

Jayden Daniels, Washington Commanders Daniels returned from damage in opposition to the Chargers on Sunday and reminded everybody why, final season, he was probably the most spectacular rookie to enter the league in a era. Daniels shredded the Chargers within the second half on the highway, lifting the Commanders to a snug win in LA.

Commercial

It hasn’t been the smoothest begin to his second season. The Commanders’ team-building strategy round Daniels has been peculiar. They’ve tried to fast-track success, recognizing they’ve hit on one thing particular with a quarterback on an affordable rookie contract. However they’re left with the oldest roster within the league by a ways. And it reveals, notably on protection.

Over the medium time period, Washington’s roster building might ding Daniels. However he stays a one-man supernova on the recreation’s most respected place. He's the closest quarterback within the league to Jackson: a precision passer who can also be electrical with the ball in his fingers as a runner. If he can push the Commanders previous the Eagles on the prime of the NFC East within the subsequent couple of years, he shall be a lock for the award.

MVP probability: 8/10. The surest participant from his vaunted rookie class to win within the subsequent three years.

Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers It was all going so nicely for Herbert and the Chargers. Two weeks into the season, it felt like this was his yr. Lastly, the items round him have been slotted into place. And the Chargers had shifted to a Herbert-centric offense, turning from a run-focused group right into a passing one. It was as if Jim Harbaugh set out with the objective of profitable Herbert the MVP award simply as a lot as he was seeking to dethrone the Chiefs within the AFC West.

Commercial

That’s modified. The Chargers have misplaced too many items alongside their offensive line. They dropped a winnable recreation in opposition to the Giants and have been hammered alongside each side of the road of scrimmage by the Commanders. The diploma of problem for Herbert at this level, this season, is just too excessive. Even to maintain the chains shifting, he has to strap on his superhero cape. That’s enjoyable in small samples – and beneficial for the MVP award when it comes below a nationwide highlight – however unsustainable over the slog of an everyday season.

Herbert has MVP expertise. When the Chargers are wholesome, he's the favourite for the award among the many gamers on this record. He matches the billing: the rule of latest, the playmaking, the profitable. He passes the attention check and holds a monopoly over a few of the fanciest metrics. Nevertheless it received’t be this yr.

MVP probability: 9/10. Ultimately, the Chargers will keep wholesome, and Herbert will break via.

Travis Hunter, Jacksonville Jaguars The MVP is a quarterback award – the final non-QB to win it was Adrian Peterson within the 2012 season. Nonetheless, enjoying on each side of the ball is an enormous assist for anybody attempting to upset the quarterback cartel.

Commercial

It’s been an inauspicious begin for Hunter as a two-way phenom. The Jags have bounced forwards and backwards between primarily utilizing him on offense and protection. Final week, they settled on a 40-snap rotation on both aspect of the ball. And that looks like the correct determine for a rookie attempting to stand up to the pace of the professional recreation whereas studying a posh offense and the league’s most disguise-laden protection.

Hunter has been fantastic as a rookie, however he hasn’t been an prompt gamechanger. There have been flashes of the expertise that made him the Heisman winner, however he has but to take over a recreation whereas enjoying each methods. Sooner or later, the Jags might choose utilizing him on one aspect whereas solely bringing him on the sector for choose packages the opposite manner. However that’s not the plan for the time being.

Which will make Hunter’s growth curve steeper, nevertheless it additionally ups his MVP potential. Who else might realistically have double-digit touchdowns as a receiver whereas additionally grabbing 5 or extra takeaways? If Hunter realizes his Ohtani-like potential on each side of the ball, voters will look previous the quarterbacks.

Commercial

MVP probability. 5/10. The one “defensive” participant who has a sniff.

Drake Maye, New England Patriots Maye burst into the nationwide highlight along with his efficiency on the highway in Buffalo on Sunday. However he has been steadily placing collectively an MVP marketing campaign all season.

The Patriots are fourth within the league in passing effectivity this yr. Plenty of that has to do with the return of Josh McDaniels. The offensive coordinator has schemed up wide-open receivers in every single place. Nevertheless it additionally speaks to Maye’s growth. He’s lower down his brain-farts-per-game from 4 to 2. He’s mastering the straightforward issues. And when the offense falls aside and he’s requested to create on his personal, he appears to be like like a mini Josh Allen.

Commercial

The superior information paints him because the fourth-most beneficial quarterback within the league this season. And it’s exhausting to disagree. His accuracy has improved. He doesn’t throw interceptions. He can rip it to all components of the sector and he's a reliable dual-threat. Oh, and he’s doing it with a so-so offensive line, a crop of operating backs who frequently fumble, and a blah batch of receivers exterior Stefon Diggs.

This yr could also be a season too early. However the Patriots ought to make the playoffs, given their begin and upcoming schedule. As they proceed so as to add expertise, Maye’s possibilities will develop.

MVP probability: 6/10. He’s engaged on the Allen timeline.

Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele, Cal Wildcard time. If Allen, Mahomes and Jackson proceed to share the MVP award amongst themselves, the subsequent first-time winner might not even be within the league but.

Commercial

Yearly when the draft rolls round, prognosticators will inform fanbases to not fear about that yr’s crop of shaky quarterback expertise. Simply wait till subsequent yr! Some organizations at all times appear to be ready for the subsequent mass inflow of proficient QBs.

Final yr was no completely different, however the 2026 draft class has to date disillusioned. Arch Manning, Garrett Nussmeier and LaNorris Sellers, shoo-ins to be excessive draft picks earlier than the season, have struggled. There isn't a sure-fire No 1 choose, however slightly a crop of eight proficient but flawed prospects that groups are contemplating on the prime of the draft.

So let’s punt even additional down the highway. Essentially the most thrilling quarterback in faculty this yr is Sagapolutele, a real freshman at Cal. The Hawaiian transferred out of Oregon after shedding a quarterback battle to Dante Moore – a possible future No 1 general choose – and already appears to be like the a part of a future franchise quarterback. A lefty, Sagapolutele is the type of clever, decisive, pocket passer that professional groups covet. He additionally occurs to have a rocket for an arm and is an explosive runner.

Commercial

Sagapolutele is not going to be eligible to enter the draft till 2028. Meaning he received’t enter actual MVP conversations for no less than 5 years, if he continues on his present trajectory. But when he have been eligible this yr, he can be the favourite to be taken No 1 general.