Hong Kong hearth got here after contractor security breaches and a residents' revolt

[ad_1] Status Development had historical past of security violations earlier than successful renovation contract, paperwork present Wang Fuk Courtroom residents wrongly instructed by marketing consultant that Status had clear security document Householders repeatedly complained about prices and hearth security after Status gained contract, tried to revoke settlement Status and marketing consultant Will Energy now topics of manslaughter and anti-corruption probes HONG KONG/SINGAPORE/BEIJING, Dec 6 (Reuters) - Householders on the advanced destroyed in one among Hong Kong's deadliest fires had been incorrectly instructed the contractor that authorities blame for the blaze had a clear security document, paperwork considered by Reuters present. Residents got the assurances by Will Energy Architects, which was retained by their householders' company to judge bids for a renovation contract, in accordance with a PowerPoint presentation created by the marketing consultant.

Join <a data-testid="Link" referrerpolicy="no-referrer-when-downgrade" href="https://www.reuters.com/world/china/hong-kong-fire-came-after-contractor-safety-breaches-residents-revolt-2025-12-06/undefined?location=article-paragraph&redirectUrl=%2Fworld%2Fchina%2Fhong-kong-fire-came-after-contractor-safety-breaches-residents-revolt-2025-12-06%2F" class="text-module__text__0GDob text-module__inherit-color__PhuPF text-module__inherit-font__1P1hv text-module__inherit-size__EyiQW link-module__link__INqxZ link-module__underline_default__-okuC">here.

In reality, the contractor, Status Development & Engineering Co., had been penalized by town's security regulator greater than a dozen instances within the seven years earlier than it was employed by the company to renovate the advanced, in accordance with the company's information, together with for improperly putting in scaffolding and defective electrical connections.

The fines had been issued for violations of an industrial-safety ordinance between 2016 and 2019, in accordance with Labour Division information. Offences below the code are sometimes prosecuted in a Justice of the Peace's courtroom.

This account of how Status gained a HK$330 million ($42.4 million) renovation contract on Will Energy's advice, in addition to the cascade of considerations about spiraling prices and hearth hazards that adopted, relies on interviews with two dozen individuals and a overview of development and regulatory information. Residents, together with some with expertise in development, repeatedly complained about workers smoking on-site and Status's use of flammable materials in locations just like the scaffolding. In addition they made an aborted effort to revoke the agency's contract. Reuters couldn't decide why Will Energy wrote within the undated presentation created for the householders' company that Status had "no document of being prosecuted by the Labour Division." The information company additionally couldn't set up whether or not the contractor disclosed the violations to Will Energy or if it contested the penalties, although the information are solely revealed on-line after any attraction has been exhausted.

Will Energy and Status didn't reply to calls and letters left at their shuttered places of work in search of remark. Reuters couldn't set up if the corporations had retained legal professionals or confirm their response to the investigations as no authorized filings have been made.

Consultants are answerable for reviewing contractors' bids, whereas contractors are required to not misrepresent or omit their security document if requested, two development trade consultants instructed Reuters.

The work of the 2 corporations is now topic to manslaughter and corruption investigations after the Nov. 26 blaze at Wang Fuk Courtroom, which has claimed <a data-testid="Link" target="_blank" referrerpolicy="no-referrer-when-downgrade" href="https://mcas-proxyweb.mcas.ms/certificate-checker?login=false&originalUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.reuters.com.mcas.ms%2Fworld%2Fchina%2Fweek-after-hong-kongs-deadly-fire-some-residents-return-belongings-2025-12-03%2F%3FMcasTsid%3D20893&McasCSRF=cb6e7bd0586d0c28ff7e161894aa0359c34bf6cec0cfce8e526288af0ec8dd34" rel="noopener" class="text-module__text__0GDob text-module__inherit-color__PhuPF text-module__inherit-font__1P1hv text-module__inherit-size__EyiQW link-module__link__INqxZ link-module__underline_default__-okuC link-module__with-icon__qlg76">at least 159 lives , opens new tab and is town's deadliest since 1948. Authorities say elements of the mesh utilized by Status on the constructing scaffolding to catch particles didn't meet fire-safety requirements and foam boards used to guard home windows throughout renovation had been extremely flammable. The Labour Division acknowledges that it instructed residents who had raised considerations earlier than the blaze that the mesh was licensed as protected. Hong Kong's deputy chief instructed reporters on Monday that contractors tried to "idiot" inspectors by mixing substandard materials with high-quality mesh. At the least three individuals accountable for Status and 4 individuals from Will Energy have been arrested within the investigations. Authorities have made extra arrests as a part of the probes, although the entire variety of individuals in custody is unclear and no costs have been introduced. Legislation enforcement has not named the arrested individuals, as is customary in Hong Kong.

Wang Fuk Courtroom consisted of eight government-subsidized housing towers constructed close to a pier and industrial property in northern Hong Kong. Its roughly 2,000 items - none bigger than 500 sq. ft (46.45 sq. meters) – had been owned by many blue-collar employees and senior residents.

Hong Kong Police and the Labour Division, which enforces security requirements at industrial websites, didn't reply to questions on their investigations and Status's security document. The labour company <a data-testid="Link" target="_blank" referrerpolicy="no-referrer-when-downgrade" href="https://mcas-proxyweb.mcas.ms/certificate-checker?login=false&originalUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.reuters.com.mcas.ms%2Fworld%2Fchina%2Fhong-kongs-deadliest-fire-decades-followed-year-safety-complaints-2025-11-28%2F%3FMcasTsid%3D20893&McasCSRF=cb6e7bd0586d0c28ff7e161894aa0359c34bf6cec0cfce8e526288af0ec8dd34" rel="noopener" class="text-module__text__0GDob text-module__inherit-color__PhuPF text-module__inherit-font__1P1hv text-module__inherit-size__EyiQW link-module__link__INqxZ link-module__underline_default__-okuC link-module__with-icon__qlg76">told Reuters , opens new tab final week that it had knowledgeable householders final yr that they confronted "comparatively low hearth dangers" after receiving repeated complaints about hearth hazards, together with the renovation mesh. Nonetheless, it mentioned that this didn't imply the company had ignored the dangers, stressing that it had reminded Status to implement fire-prevention measures. The Buildings Division, which units pointers on development supplies however is separate from the labour company, referred Reuters to 2 paperwork it had despatched to development corporations in October and November. The notices urged them to “take immediate motion” in making certain that development supplies just like the mesh netting met fire-safety requirements, however didn't particularly reference foam boards.

Messages despatched by Reuters to an adviser of the previous management of the company in search of remark went unanswered.

RESIDENTS REVOLT Hong Kong laws require buildings which might be greater than 30 years previous to bear inspections and renovations a minimum of as soon as.

The work at Wang Fuk Courtroom, which was constructed within the Nineteen Eighties, entailed refurbishment of the outside cladding, fixing hearth security options and changing water pipes.

Status was employed after Will Energy awarded its bid one of many highest grades among the many 57 bids and mentioned it had a spotless security document.

Labour Division information reviewed by Reuters, nevertheless, present that Status had been fined a cumulative HK$309,000 ($39,700) for 15 office security violations dedicated between September 2016 and June 2019. The company didn't reply when requested about Status's document.

Individually, the Buildings Division ordered Status and an affiliated individual to pay a complete of HK$139,000 ($17,850) for “negligence or misconduct” and processing prices associated to 2 tasks from 2012 and 2014, information revealed within the authorities gazette in 2023 present. The company additionally barred Status from performing sure tasks for 4 months.

Issues with the renovation began changing into obvious in early 2024, when the authorized whole value of the mission greater than doubled from the roughly HK$150 million ($19.3 million) introduced through the bid because the scope of works expanded, in accordance with minutes from a January 28 householders' company assembly.

In Hong Kong, such firms characterize the homeowners of house items in overseeing the administration and upkeep of an property.

The following month, a resident submitted to the company's administration signatures of plenty of householders, hoping to set off a particular assembly to interchange the long-serving management and revoke Status's contract.

Householders needed to interchange the management primarily resulting from considerations over how shortly Status needed to be paid, the present head of the supervisory physique of residents instructed Reuters. Assembly minutes additionally present residents repeatedly complained about "sky-high" prices and never being completely consulted on the scope of works.

However the prior householders’ board questioned the validity of the signatures and warned {that a} "particular assembly wastes money and time and damages relationships," in accordance with bulletins revealed on the advanced's web site.

The assembly was lastly convened throughout a hurricane on Sept. 6, 2024, seven months after the primary request. Greater than 1,200 individuals braved the climate to attend the gathering that stretched till 11 p.m.

By the tip of the night, new management of the householders’ board had been put in.

FIRE HAZARDS The brand new board finally didn't revoke Status's contract after being instructed by a lawyer the transfer would go away all homeowners legally liable, the minutes present, with out specifying the dangers.

The lawyer, Walter Tsui of WT Legislation Places of work, confirmed he knowledgeable the homeowners of their potential legal responsibility however mentioned he didn't bear in mind specifics. He instructed Reuters he was invited to the assembly by the brand new board and wasn't representing any social gathering: "I solely gave my opinion when residents requested me about it."

The brand new board instantly launched a overview of the renovation mission that included trying into fire-safety dangers. It additionally mobilised volunteer groups of residents with expertise in development to assist oversee the location, whereas gathering photographic proof of potential breaches, movies posted to the company's web site present.

"Will there be any corner-cutting? Any violations of security pointers? Any lack of follow-up? Don’t fear - our supervisory taskforce will maintain a detailed watch,” the householders' company mentioned in a video on the advanced's web site.

Regardless of the brand new workforce's efforts, which included a September 2024 assembly with Status at which it was requested to clarify the protection of a few of its supplies, some residents nonetheless felt they needed to take issues into their very own fingers.

Retired electrician and plumber Wong, the topic of a broadly circulated Reuters <a data-testid="Link" target="_blank" referrerpolicy="no-referrer-when-downgrade" href="https://mcas-proxyweb.mcas.ms/certificate-checker?login=false&originalUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.reuters.com.mcas.ms%2Finvestigates%2Fspecial-report%2Fhongkong-fire-wongfamily-picture%2F%3FMcasTsid%3D20893&McasCSRF=cb6e7bd0586d0c28ff7e161894aa0359c34bf6cec0cfce8e526288af0ec8dd34" rel="noopener" class="text-module__text__0GDob text-module__inherit-color__PhuPF text-module__inherit-font__1P1hv text-module__inherit-size__EyiQW link-module__link__INqxZ link-module__underline_default__-okuC link-module__with-icon__qlg76">photograph , opens new tab that confirmed him in despair as Wang Fuk Courtroom burned behind him together with his spouse trapped inside, ripped out foam boards masking his home windows and changed them with fire-retardant plastic movie, his son instructed Reuters. Wong additionally frequently sprayed water onto the mesh outdoors his flat to maintain it moist, mentioned his son, J Wong, who like his father declined to present his full title.

"Regardless of figuring out the dangers, it doesn't matter what he did, he could not change what occurred," J Wong mentioned.

Extra reporting by Selena Li, James Pomfret and Jessie Pang in Hong Kong; Modifying by Katerina Ang

Our Requirements: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. , opens new tab

Purchase Licensing Rights Mei Mei Chu makes a speciality of home governance, human rights, and overseas coverage engagements. She beforehand specialised in China’s agriculture sector, reporting on meals safety and the U.S.-China commerce battle. Previous to her posting in China, she was Reuters Commodities Correspondent in Malaysia, the place she uncovered pressured labour abuses throughout the nation’s manufacturing and agricultural firms. She started her journalism profession at Malaysia’s largest English-language newspaper and is an alumna of the Oxford Local weather Journalism Community. She brings a cross-disciplinary lens to her protection of coverage and diplomacy.

Antoni Slodkowski is Reuters Chief Politics & Normal Information Correspondent for China, based mostly in Beijing, the place he leads protection of Chinese language politics, society, and its relations with international counterparts. He has gained two Pulitzer Prizes with Reuters colleagues: in Investigative Reporting in 2025 for uncovering fentanyl provide chains, and in Worldwide Reporting in 2019 for exposing the persecution of Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar. Beforehand Japan Deputy Bureau Chief and Myanmar Bureau Chief at Reuters, Antoni additionally reported from Tokyo for the Monetary Instances and was a Knight-Wallace Fellow on the College of Michigan. He started his journalism profession as a young person, internet hosting a youngsters's TV present for Poland's largest public broadcaster.