'It felt so unsuitable': Colin Angle on iRobot, the FTC, and the Amazon deal that by no means was

[ad_1] When iRobot filed for Chapter 11 chapter final Sunday, it marked the top of an period for one among America’s most beloved robotics firms. The Roomba maker, which had bought over 50 million robots since its 2002 launch, had survived 35 years of near-death experiences and technical challenges solely to be undone by what founder Colin Angle calls “avoidable” regulatory opposition.

The collapse adopted Amazon’s January 2024 choice to scuttle its $1.7 billion acquisition of iRobot after 18 months of investigation by the FTC and European regulators. On this candid dialog, Angle displays on what he describes as a profoundly irritating course of, the chilling message it sends to entrepreneurs, and his dedication to maneuver ahead with a brand new enterprise in shopper robotics.

This interview has been edited for size and readability.

TC: You known as the chapter “avoidable” and a “tragedy for shoppers.” Stroll me via what you assume regulators received unsuitable in blocking the Amazon acquisition.

CA: I feel there’s an actual lesson across the position of the FTC and the European Fee. The aim, after all, is to keep away from the abuses that may occur in monopolies and with the aim of defending shopper alternative and defending innovation.

What occurred was that iRobot and Amazon got here collectively for the expressed goal of making extra innovation, extra shopper alternative, at a time when iRobot’s trajectory was actually totally different from the place it was a number of years earlier. Within the EU, we had a 12% market share [but it was] declining the place the primary competitor was solely three years outdated available in the market, which is sort of the definition of a vibrant and dynamic market. And in the USA, iRobot’s market share was increased, nevertheless it was declining and there have been a number of rising opponents bringing outdoors innovation into {the marketplace}.

This could have been a no brainer. This could have been three, 4 weeks of investigation. What occurred as a substitute was a yr and a half of pendency, which had a really difficult affect on the power to function an organization and in the end having the acquisition blocked.

Techcrunch occasion

San Francisco | October 13-15, 2026

What was that 18-month course of really like? What had been you being requested to do?

The quantity of time and cash spent was indescribable. I might not be shocked if over 100,000 paperwork had been created and delivered. iRobot invested a big a part of our discretionary earnings in opposition to fulfilling the necessities that went together with doing the transaction. Amazon was compelled to take a position many, many, many instances that. There was an entire group, each inside and exterior workers and legal professionals and economists working to attempt to, in as many various methods as potential — as a result of it appeared like our message was falling on deaf ears — display that this acquisition was not going to create a monopolistic state of affairs.

There was every day exercise for 18 months related to this. Maybe most telling, once I was testifying as a part of being deposed, I had an opportunity to stroll the halls of the FTC. The examiners on their workplace doorways had printouts of offers blocked, like trophies.

Trophies?

To me, it felt so unsuitable as an entrepreneur who began this factor actually in my front room and lived six and a half years by no means having sufficient cash within the financial institution to make payroll, lastly making it via succeeding. Right here’s an company whose said mission is defending shopper pursuits and serving to the USA financial system, celebrating as victories each time they shut down M&A, which in a really possible way is the first driver of worth creation for the innovation financial system.

I went into this deposition searching for a buddy. It’s like, “Right here we're, we’re clearly not in a stronger place, and right here’s an awesome alternative for us. Are you excited for us?” Possibly that is simply my naïve take popping out, however that’s not the reception I received. It was, “Why ought to we ever allow them to do that?” It’s like: as a result of it’s good for the patron — as a result of it’s going to catalyze innovation.

How do you assume what occurred right here adjustments the calculus for startup founders who see acquisition as their exit technique? Do you assume we’re in a world the place American tech firms can’t scale via M&A?

Threat has a chilling impact. For those who’re an entrepreneur, your solely choice is to hope that it doesn’t occur once more. The rationale you and I are speaking is I hope by my phrases I could make it much less possible that it'll occur once more.

I based a brand new firm and my outlook on exit technique and even commercialization technique is impacted by the experiences I had at iRobot. How can it not be? That precedent creates danger of it taking place once more, and solely via constructive experiences will we begin to dial down the anxiousness that the exits I’m relying on — or as a enterprise capitalist, the exits I’m investing in assuming will occur — will really come via. That danger is factored into the willingness to take a position, the valuation of offers, and the speed of latest firm formation.

It’s onerous to say there’s X p.c fewer entrepreneurial begins or exits because of the chilling message, nevertheless it definitely didn’t assist. Entrepreneurs can use each leg up that we as a nation can present. It's a rugged journey. When it really works out, it ought to be a celebration. The FTC is there as a safeguard in opposition to very actual examples of issues gone too far. I’m an enormous believer in checks and balances. However when issues get out of whack, the nation suffers.

Let’s speak about iRobot’s journey. The Roomba didn’t come out for 12 years after the corporate was based. Inform me about these early days.

iRobot was a bunch of individuals in a tutorial lab saying, “We had been promised robots. The place are the robots?” If I might be pissed off that I don’t have the robots we had been promised, I ought to do one thing about it. If not us, who? If not now, when?

One of many co-founders, my professor Rod Brooks, had pioneered an AI know-how which allowed the embedding of machine intelligence in low-cost robotics. The mission of the corporate was to construct cool stuff, ship an awesome product, have enjoyable, earn money, and alter the world.

The primary marketing strategy was “personal mission to the moon, promote the film rights.” We had been possibly the primary firm to fail to do precisely that. However the know-how we developed led to additions to the Mars Pathfinder mission — my title’s up on Mars. We constructed robots that went into the Gulf of Mexico after the Deepwater Horizon catastrophe. We constructed the PackBot, which was the primary robotic ever deployed in a fight mission for the US Military, went into caves in Afghanistan, and have become the first methodology for diffusing improvised explosive units. We'd get postcards: “You saved my life as we speak.”

When the Fukushima catastrophe occurred, we donated half one million {dollars} price of robots to Japan. We despatched six individuals over to coach Tokyo Electrical Energy Firm workers. These robots had been the primary contained in the reactor doorways, mapped out radiation ranges, and located a path the place an worker may run in, get to the management room, work for a minute and a half, run again out, and solely obtain a lifetime dose of radiation. We had been credited with enabling the shutdown of the reactor.

After which yr 12, the Roomba?

I had a group that was engaged on toys, and one of many guys mentioned, “Colin, I feel it’s time we will do that. We will lastly make the vacuum.” I’m like, “Okay, right here’s $15,000. Two weeks. See what you are able to do.” Two weeks later they got here again and mentioned, “Hey, that’s not dangerous. Possibly there’s one thing right here.” We scraped and located a bit bit of cash [to build these]. A yr and a half later, I satisfied my board that we may construct 10,000 of those robots and we launched them.

It’s actually the media that picked up the story. We had no cash for advertising. Reporters had been fascinated as a result of we tended to do fascinating issues that had been actual, and so they couldn’t consider that robotic vacuuming may probably be actual. [The reaction was:] “My God, it really labored.” We ended up promoting 70,000 robots within the first three months. Then we practically went out of enterprise the following yr.

Since you couldn’t accommodate demand?

As a result of we screwed up. The press drove this big preliminary demand — 70,000 robots. So subsequent yr we’re going to do 4 instances that. We made 300,000 robots. We even made a tv business, however we had been a bunch of geek engineers, so it completely failed. After Cyber Monday we had been sitting with 250,000 robots in our warehouse like, “Oh my God, the world’s going to finish.”

Then one thing good occurred. The man working our web site mentioned, “Why did gross sales quadruple yesterday?” We hadn’t completed something. What had occurred was Pepsi had began working a TV advert with Dave Chappelle. He walks into this lovely residence, picks up a potato chip, and a Roomba comes out. He’s like, “A vacuum cleaner!” He throws down the potato chip, the vacuum eats it, then chases him. His pants are ripped off. He stands up in boxers. A wonderful girl seems, and he says, “Your vacuum cleaner ate my pants.” We bought 250,000 robots in two weeks and realized we knew nothing about advertising.

Wow! You had no concept Pepsi was incorporating your product into its business?

No concept. It was wild. You attempt to do good for therefore lengthy and also you get smacked within the face so many instances, after which typically one thing good occurs. You might say due to that loopy second in time, now we have robots. After we take into consideration simply how fragile a journey it's — cats using Roombas was an enormous a part of why we succeeded. Does that make any sense? No, under no circumstances. However we definitely didn’t count on tens of billions of views of cats using Roombas.

In some unspecified time in the future you began seeing Chinese language opponents like Roborock and Ecovacs adopting lidar navigation years earlier than iRobot. Why did you follow vision-based navigation for therefore lengthy?

We explicitly didn't put lasers on the robotic. We had the know-how many years in the past as a result of it’s a dead-end know-how. Beneath my strategic course, we had been going to take a position each penny of price in opposition to a vision-based nav and situational understanding system. Your Tesla doesn't have a laser on it. It's all vision-based. At the very least Elon agrees with me.

Our strategic plan was for Roomba to be rather more than only a vacuum cleaner within the residence. To do this, it wants to know extra. Lasers should not superior know-how — they’ve been round for many years. They’re an expedient resolution to a subset of the issues {that a} robotic at residence must tackle. A laser won't ever let you know whether or not you really cleaned the ground or not.

It's completely true that Chinese language competitors was coming in at cheaper price factors. We had been late in constructing a two-in-one robotic — we believed that by separating mopping and vacuuming you could possibly give a greater buyer expertise. The client voted that we had been unsuitable, and that’s okay. We definitely had been first in auto-evac, first in navigation. We had been additionally importantly excluded from the Chinese language market, which is the most important marketplace for shopper robotics on this planet. That didn’t assist.

What learnings out of your iRobot expertise would you share with different robotics entrepreneurs?

The very first thing I inform all robotics entrepreneurs is: ensure you perceive your market so that you're constructing one thing that delivers extra worth than it prices to create. Robots are so thrilling, so horny that it’s very easy to persuade your self that you simply’re doing one thing that's going to alter the world, if solely shoppers had been good sufficient to appreciate it. That’s a fairly powerful equation.

Know-how is oftentimes within the robotic area properly forward of the enterprise plans that may reap the benefits of the know-how. One of many traps is considering of robotics as a factor versus a toolkit. As quickly as you say, “I’m going to construct a robotic,” and head off constructing your humanoid — are you actually doing it since you perceive an issue you’re making an attempt to resolve, or are you enamored with constructing your factor?

Once I began iRobot, it was simply assumed that robots had been going to hoover flooring by constructing humanoids to push upright vacuum cleaners. After we first constructed Roomba, we might ask individuals, “Is {that a} robotic?” Individuals would say, “No, that’s not a robotic. A robotic has legs and arms and a head.” But Roomba on the time price 10,000 instances lower than a humanoid pushing an upright vacuum.

The problem of entrepreneurship is breaking via the romance and alternative and falling in love along with your know-how and attending to the applying that you simply’re making an attempt to resolve. Perceive your shopper, perceive the issue you’re making an attempt to resolve — as a result of it’s sophisticated, robotics is dear, and it takes loads of vitality to get proper.

You talked about you’ve based a brand new firm. What are you able to inform me about it?

We’re in stealth mode, however I’ll offer you a broad trace. It’s consumer-facing. We’re actually taking a look at the truth that a lot of the issues robots can do to satisfy excellent wants require us to work together with different individuals. So how will we construct a robotic that truly has adequate emotional sophistication — not human-level, however sufficient — to construct an everlasting co-character that may make sense over time and use that for well being and wellness associated functions?

It’s going to be superior. I’m so enthusiastic about it. It’s given me enthusiasm and vitality to have an opportunity to make use of this new toolkit and proceed on my journey to construct the robots we had been promised. I actually haven’t modified that a lot from a grad pupil in school saying, “Oh my God, we’ve been promised robots and we don’t have those that I need but.” I spent 30 years centered on constructing the world’s best ground care robotic, and now I've an opportunity to do one thing else.

For extra from this interview with Angle, together with his tackle whether or not humanoid robots will ever work, take a look at TechCrunch’s StrictlyVC Obtain podcast — new episodes drop each Tuesday, and the total dialog will likely be accessible quickly.