The perplexing rise of protein shakes: how a ‘meaty sludge’ grew to become a billion-dollar trade

[ad_1] I at all times thought my first foray into Michelin-starred culinary territory would contain sitting in a elaborate restaurant feasting on some completely seared scallops or a powerful rack of lamb doused in a wealthy jus. As a substitute, I’m in a health studio – with Doja Cat blaring by the audio system – watching my “Michelin-starred” shake come collectively in a blender. Inside is a scoop of vanilla protein powder, the flesh of a guanabana (a tropical fruit with a spiky exterior that tastes like a cross between a mango and a banana) and a few almond milk. Saffron foam is sprayed right into a plastic cup and sprinkled with some blue spirulina earlier than the pale protein combination is poured on high.

The Guardian’s journalism is impartial. We are going to earn a fee in the event you purchase one thing by an affiliate hyperlink. Study extra.

The ensuing shake, which was developed by the Michelin-starred chef Miller Prada for Hermosa, a luxurious protein powder model bought in Barry’s, a sequence of health studios, is sort of a drinkable lava lamp, with white, blue and yellow swirling softly within the cup. In keeping with Erika Tamayo, the founding father of Hermosa, it has just one comparability. “Everybody says that it appears like Vincent van Gogh’s Starry Evening,” she says. Earlier than I’m allowed to style it, she spritzes a coffee-scented liquid on the lid after which tells me tips on how to drink it to get the “full Michelin expertise”. Place the straw about halfway within the cup and suck (it ought to style like an ice-cream), earlier than shoving it down full-throttle to get successful of the “mood-enhancing” saffron.

So, pomp apart, how does it style? Fairly good. The feel is easy and creamy (not like the various gravel-textured protein shakes I’ve downed earlier than) and the guanabana gives a refined sweetness. Would I get it once more? Perhaps. The primary factor holding me again is the hefty £11 price ticket – although this appears to be the going charge for a elaborate shake.

‘Everybody says that it appears like Vincent van Gogh’s Starry Evening’ … the ‘Michelin-starred’ shake. {Photograph}: David Levene/The Guardian “We made this shake as an announcement. Folks are actually understanding that well being is luxurious, and everyone seems to be investing in it,” says Tamayo. She is just not the one one creating “assertion” protein shakes within the UK. Elevate, which calls itself a “nutrition-focused beverage outlet” in central London, sells an £8.90 cacao shake filled with 21g of protein that guarantees to “help temper and convey a mild, uplifting increase”. Equally, Soho Home members can deal with themselves to a brand new suite of vibrant, “protein-based smoothies”, priced at about £9 every, with names that wouldn’t go amiss on a cocktail menu: “The Berlin”, “The Shoreditch” and “The Seaside Home”.

These visually engaging, nutrient-packed well being drinks actually took off with the viral rise of the LA-based luxurious wellness grocery shops Erewhon. Whereas customers there can feast on a single strawberry imported from Japan for $20 (£15.20), or guzzle a bottle of “hyper-oxygenated” water for $26, it’s the mega-viral smoothies, which may value greater than $20 a pop, which have catapulted the model to social media stardom. Most of them aren’t protein-based, however their putting look (excellent for an Instagram snap) and use of elements that may apparently provide you with glazed pores and skin and even cognitive help have impressed a brand new flock of imitators. They've turn out to be so common that among the largest stars on the planet, together with Sabrina Carpenter, Olivia Rodrigo and Bella Hadid, have lent their names to limited-edition Erewhon smoothies. And Erewhon has raked in big earnings in consequence: $171.4m in 2023, the final yr for which figures can be found, regardless of solely having 11 places in a single US state: California.

For Tamayo, style, presentation and spectacle are key to standing out within the protein powder market, which has by no means been larger (globally, it has been valued at $24.8bn, in line with the market analysis agency Analysis and Markets). In addition to its Michelin-starred shake, Hermosa sells “grass-fed whey protein” in an amber glass jar (containing 14 servings) for £38.

Protein is booming throughout the board. A YouGov survey carried out earlier this yr discovered that 25% of UK adults repeatedly drink protein shakes, together with 37% of 25 to 34-year-olds. The trade has grown so large, actually, that there's now a scarcity of whey, the once-discarded liquid byproduct of cheese-making that has turn out to be an ingredient utilized in most protein powders; it has additionally soared in value. So how did the world go wild for protein shakes?

Bob Hoffman would chuck Hershey’s chocolate into every batch of his protein shakes till they tasted edible Most protein powders and shakes bought right this moment sound as in the event that they have been taken straight from a dessert menu (chocolate, Biscoff and even matcha) however, of their first iteration, they resembled extra of a meaty “sludge”, says Hannah Chopping-Jones, a meals historian on the College of Oregon. The primary protein-based product bought to shoppers dates again to 1865, when a German scientist, Justus von Liebig, invented a meat substitute, marketed as Extract of Meat, which consisted of jars of “melted-down beef hides and carcasses”. It was really useful that buyers drink a “small wine-glassful” two to 3 occasions a day. “To name it a protein shake can be very beneficiant,” says Chopping-Jones, nevertheless it was the primary product “touted as having a variety of protein”. The sludge was finally changed into stable cubes and have become a house cooking staple underneath a extra acquainted title, Oxo.

Most protein energy is made out of whey, which has soared in value. {Photograph}: Andreas Hauslbetz/Alamy Quickly after, protein merchandise discovered a foothold amongst males in search of to buff up. From the late Eighteen Nineties, Plasmon, a boxed milk protein powder plastered with photos of Greek gods and muscular males, was bought throughout the UK and Germany. It was endorsed by the bodybuilder Eugen Sandow, who would go on to supply his personal product: Well being and Power Cocoa, the world’s first chocolate protein powder. However Chopping-Jones says protein shakes actually took off after the second world battle, when meals expertise underwent a revolution. “They freeze-dried issues, they turned milk into powder, and dehydrated eggs and cheeses to get them as light-weight as potential for rations bins,” which, she says, normalised getting our vitamins from powders.

The protein trade noticed its first main success within the Fifties with the introduction of Tremendous Hello-Protein shakes, developed by the then-head coach of the US Olympic weightlifting workforce, Bob Hoffman. “That is most likely the earliest instance of a shake that might resemble something like [what] we've right this moment,” says Chopping-Jones (besides that, as a substitute of the nutritionally fine-tuned powders we’re used to, Hoffman would chuck Hershey’s chocolate into every batch till it tasted edible). By 1960, the product had achieved greater than $1m in gross sales, Chopping-Jones says. The Nineteen Seventies noticed protein shakes making their first vital forays past the fitness center, with two common diets, the low-carbohydrate Atkins weight loss program and the all-liquid Final Probability weight loss program, the place these trying to shed extra pounds quick have been suggested to eat nothing however protein shakes. So many Individuals signed as much as the latter weight loss program, 2 million by some estimates, that the New York Instances steered that “sipping [a supplement] as a substitute of martinis” was now customary at cocktail events. It fell out of favour when the US authorities investigated whether or not starvation-related deaths could possibly be attributed to it.

‘We made this shake as an announcement’ … chef Miller Prada and Erika Tamayo with the Miller Prada x Hermosa shake “Folks have been beginning to join protein with weight reduction within the 70s and 80s,” says Chopping-Jones, which was a “actually key turning level for protein shakes”, although they nonetheless, for essentially the most half, remained a bodybuilding staple. Within the early 00s, this started to vary. As much as that time, dieters have been instructed that their splendid physique could possibly be achieved by avoiding fats. This longstanding assumption was shattered when research discovered that folks consuming a low-carbohydrate, high-protein weight loss program misplaced extra weight than these on a low-fat, low-cholesterol, low-calorie weight loss program. The Atkins weight loss program returned and protein grew in reputation. In keeping with the Economist, international gross sales of sports activities diet merchandise, most of them protein-based, doubled from 2007 to 2013, to £260m. Chopping-Jones says that from this level onwards, protein has “actually been off to the races” as a result of it could possibly be marketed to everyone. UK-based MaxiMuscle, which went from £8.6m in gross sales in 2004 to £80m by 2010, broadened its attraction by releasing a product line geared toward ladies in 2006, and in 2012 it launched an promoting marketing campaign for “actual males”. This confirmed an workplace employee lifting a automotive in a single hand and ingesting a shake within the different. By 2011, its merchandise have been stocked in main supermarkets, together with Tesco and Sainsbury’s.

Social media was the subsequent foot on the protein pedal. The prevailing message, often delivered by ripped (female and male) health influencers, was: “You’re going to have the ability to seem like me in the event you purchase this protein powder,” says Chopping-Jones, who calls it “a marketer’s dream come true”. MyProtein, which was arrange in 2004 with a £500 overdraft earlier than hovering to its present valuation of a minimum of £400m, grew to become the influencers’ model of selection within the 2010s, however love for the merchandise was most likely not the one purpose for plugging its shakes. The agency has had a long-running model ambassador marketing campaign the place, as of 2025, influencers with greater than 10,000 followers can earn as much as 8% fee on every MyProtein product bought.

However how a lot protein do we actually want? The UK authorities says that males aged 19-50 needs to be consuming about 55g of protein a day, roughly equal to 9 eggs, and ladies in the identical age bracket ought to eat about 45g, about the identical as seven eggs. In keeping with Dr Linia Patel, a nutritionist at Pure Sports activities Drugs, these suggestions are “extra about stopping malnutrition” and, as a place to begin, to thrive individuals needs to be “consuming about 1g per kilogram of physique weight, or 1.2g in the event that they’re lively”.

Patel says protein helps us really feel fuller for longer as a result of it’s a “advanced molecule”. Because of this once we eat it, it takes “slightly bit extra work for our our bodies to metabolise and digest it”, however there's such a factor as an excessive amount of protein. Patel says going above 2g to 2.2g per kg of physique weight constantly – as anybody on the all-animal-product carnivore weight loss program may, as an example – might be an excessive amount of protein, as a result of it dangers “displacing different key vitamins”, together with fibre.

‘Complete meals sources reminiscent of meats, fish and eggs are filled with vitamins, minerals and compounds that dietary supplements can’t replicate.’ {Photograph}: Tatjana Baibakova/Alamy Relating to discovering the easiest way of consuming protein, she says, “Meals first needs to be our precedence” as a result of entire meals sources reminiscent of meats, fish and eggs are filled with vitamins, minerals and compounds “that dietary supplements can’t replicate”. Nevertheless, protein powders can have their place. “We have to use them as a device, v being your go-to,” she says. She recommends going for an unflavoured powder as a daily possibility as a result of “there’s a number of sweeteners and emulsifiers” in closely flavoured choices. And in the event you’re making a shake to exchange a meal, including elements reminiscent of Greek yoghurt, fruit or nut butters may also help make it extra “balanced”.

It’s not simply shakes and powders which have benefited from the protein craze. A 2023 research discovered about 1,200 merchandise making protein claims on UK grocery store cabinets, together with cereals, cheese and even pancakes. Dr Ada Garcia, a public well being nutritionist on the College of Glasgow, who led the research, says most of those meals met a dietary threshold to be “categorized as wholesome”, however she cautions customers to concentrate to how these protein claims are phrased.

Beneath EU legal guidelines, that are nonetheless in place within the UK, for a product to be labelled a “supply of protein”, the nutrient should make up a minimum of 12% of its power worth. If one thing is labelled “excessive protein”, 20% of the product’s power worth have to be offered by protein. Different phrases are extra of a minefield. “There are issues that producers can say, for instance: {that a} meals gives a protein kick or a protein increase or is wealthy in protein. These claims aren't regulated to allow them to add no matter quantity of protein they like,” says Garcia.

Protein mania reveals no indicators of slowing down, however at what level does it tip into an unhealthy obsession? Final yr, the Grocer revealed a survey that discovered 77% of individuals within the UK wish to eat extra protein, greater than every other nutrient, together with fibre (60%), probiotics (48%) and, unsurprisingly, fats (9%). “Persons are actually nervous that they’re not getting sufficient protein, and I believe a variety of social media influencers are actually banking on that,” says Chopping-Jones.

TikTok is stuffed with movies of younger individuals dry-scooping – the place protein powders are eaten uncooked, with none liquid. Chopping-Jones says this harmful pattern (well being consultants have warned that it could possibly trigger choking or an infection) reveals how issues have “spiralled” uncontrolled in relation to monitoring our vitamins. “We shouldn’t substitute all the opposite aspects of what meals is by counting our each calorie and macronutrient consumption. We’re not robots – meals is about being human,” she says.