Trump administration tells states to finish ‘orphan tax’ on foster youngsters : NPR

[ad_1] <img src="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/4000x2667+0+0/resize/1100/quality/50/format/jpeg/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2F5d%2Ff5%2F72f9d6424a7b9dd589506bc2c35a%2Fgettyimages-2225585758.jpg" data-template="https://npr.brightspotcdn.com/dims3/default/strip/false/crop/4000x2667+0+0/resize/{width}/quality/{quality}/format/{format}/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fnpr-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2F5d%2Ff5%2F72f9d6424a7b9dd589506bc2c35a%2Fgettyimages-2225585758.jpg" class="img" alt="A man in a dark suit, white shirt and blue tie, with short hair and wearing glasses, sits at a table in a congressional hearing room and speaks into a microphone. " fetchpriority="high"/> Alex Adams, assistant secretary of the Division of Well being and Human Providers, throughout his Senate Finance Committee affirmation listening to in Washington, D.C., on July 22, 2025. Eric Lee/Bloomberg/Bloomberg through Getty Pictures/Bloomberg disguise caption

toggle caption

Eric Lee/Bloomberg/Bloomberg through Getty Pictures/Bloomberg The Trump Administration has instructed states to cease the long-standing follow of taking Social Safety profit checks from some youngsters and youth in foster care.

In a letter to governors, despatched in early December, Alex Adams, an assistant secretary of the U.S. Division of Well being and Human Providers, instructed states to finish what he calls "the orphan tax."

Adams, who oversees federal youngster welfare coverage, instructed states to stop taking Social Safety survivor advantages from youngsters in foster care. The month-to-month profit is paid to a baby whose mom or father has died however had labored and paid Social Safety taxes.

States routinely take these checks from youngsters and youth who're in foster care as reimbursement for the price of a baby's care — though, by legislation, states are required to supply foster care to all youngsters who want it.

"There isn't any ethical justification for why orphans ought to need to pay their very own manner," Adams instructed NPR. "They aren't in foster care by any fault of their very own. They usually definitely shouldn't be requested to pay their very own invoice."

An NPR investigation with The Marshall Venture in 2021 uncovered the difficulty of states taking survivor profit checks from youngsters in foster care.

Since then, Democratic and Republican leaders in a number of states and cities have moved to finish the follow.

The typical month-to-month survivor profit test is round $1,100.

For a kid who has misplaced a father or mother, that cash may also help stabilize a household. When the kid is in foster care, the cash may be put aside for after they depart care and haven't got a father or mother to assist them pay for school or hire or a automobile to get to a job.

These Social Safety advantages, Adams says, "may be the final sources that your deceased mother and father may depart behind for his or her youngsters. To have these taken from that youngster and utilized to state company prices — that is why I name it an orphan tax. It is morally stunning to me and it is morally corrupt."

He provides: "Charles Dickens could not have conceived of a plot this cynical."

Justin Kasieta is aware of this. He instructed his story to Adams: That he was 13 when his father died from most cancers, and the survivor profit saved his household collectively for some time. However when his mom struggled with well being points, Kasieta and his 4 siblings went into foster care.

Kasieta says the state of Michigan cashed $18,000 of his checks over three years.

Nearly each youngster who goes into foster care is impoverished and virtually all depart foster care broke. Kasieta, now 25, obtained scholarships to school and has a job at a company funding financial institution in Atlanta.

"I prefer to make it clear that I am actually the exception to the rule," Kasieta says. "Sadly, the rule is that the majority youngsters will develop into homeless. They will not go to school. They are going to be unemployed. "

"I actually assume if we wish to make tales like mine the rule as an alternative of the exception, we now have to assist youngsters as they're popping out of foster care," he says. "You possibly can't take their cash."

Adams modified the coverage in Idaho when he served as director of the state's Division of Well being and Welfare. When he took the job, a colleague despatched him an article concerning the follow of cashing survivor advantages.

"Frankly, my first response in Idaho was there isn't any manner that is really taking place," he says. When he gathered his employees, they instructed him it was true. He moved earlier this yr to finish the follow.

In his new job, operating the Administration for Kids & Households on the U.S. Division of Well being and Human Providers, Adams shortly despatched the notification to governors of 39 remaining states to alter their insurance policies.

His boss, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., endorsed the transfer. "At HHS, our guideline is easy: each youngster deserves a house and a good likelihood to thrive. However when state businesses stack the deck towards youngsters, we step in," Kennedy mentioned in a press release and in a video with Adams.

At ACF, Adams oversees federal funding of kid care and Head Begin. Late final month, ACF halted funds for youngster care packages in Minnesota.

Motion to ensure foster youngsters their profit checks has gained assist throughout political events.

The Biden Administration took some steps, too. Officers at HHS and the Social Safety Administration despatched letters suggesting states rethink taking survivor advantages, however left the states with leeway to behave.

Now there's new momentum as conservatives — within the Trump Administration and in states — decide up the difficulty.

Amy Harfeld, on the Kids's Advocacy Institute on the College of San Diego Faculty of Regulation, has lengthy pushed for reform. She says conservatives are becoming a member of as a result of they see the query as "authorities overreach into youngsters' personal belongings. As a result of it wasn't the state's cash to take they usually took it anyway."

Some state officers have argued this can be a budgetary problem. They want the cash.

However Adams rejects that. He was additionally as soon as Idaho's price range director, the place he minimize packages.

"I used to be type of seen as Ebenezer Scrooge once I was our state price range director. At no level would I've regarded to steadiness our price range on the backs of orphans."

Adams says states needn't as a result of these Social Safety survivor advantages do not add as much as a lot. He estimates they whole about $34 million nationwide.

"That is a fraction of 1 % of the full youngster welfare invoice that is paid by the federal and state and native governments," he says.

There is a comparable however more durable problem to resolve. Along with survivor profit checks, states additionally money the incapacity checks of children in foster care.

In contrast to with survivor advantages, there is a restrict on how a lot anybody can preserve in Supplemental Safety Earnings, or SSI advantages. In consequence, state youngster welfare businesses would wish to take additional steps to return these checks to youngsters in foster care.